Monday, June 8, 2009
Saturday, June 6, 2009
Adiga: India's stagnant, corrupt socialist economy......
Q: What were some of the challenges or advantages of writing two books at the same time?
A: Between the Assassinations and The White Tiger were conceived as two books that would tell one story. It was always my plan to create two narratives about India, set on either side of the landmark year of 1991, when the stagnant, corrupt socialist economy was opened up to capitalism and globalization. These forces created the "new India" – of rapid economic growth and massive inequality – which is the India of The White Tiger.
Between the Assassinations tells the story of the final years of the old India. In that sense, the two books complemented one another quite well. In fact, The White Tiger grew out of a couple of the stories in Between the Assassinations. There are echoes of The White Tiger in Between the Assassinations. At least one vignette in Between the Assassinations – which was first published inThe New Yorker as "The Elephant" – features a poor man tempted by violence and crime, but then takes a very different turn from The White Tiger.
Q: What appeals to you about the seven-day time frame as a structural device?
A: Since the two books were written at the same time, and they are mirror images of each other, it follows that the structure of the stories is also somehow similar.
Q: What is significant about the time between the Gandhi assassinations?
A: The assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in 1984 traumatized India, but it also opened up the possibility that the economically stagnant and corrupt India that she had created could be reformed and modernized. But after a promising start, the man who replaced her as prime minister – her son, Rajiv – failed to change India, and his years in power were years of frustrated hope and failed dreams.
Q: How is the India of that time different from the more contemporary India of The White Tiger?
A: It was only after Rajiv's death that the old India was finally swept away. The years between the assassinations are the last years of the old regime. They are a time of dashed hopes and of crisis; yet the men and women who endured these years did so by learning the virtues of perseverance, resignation and compassion – virtues that have become less conspicuous in the new India of The White Tiger. In that sense, Between the Assassinations is not a prelude to The White Tiger but presents an alternative vision of India – and poses a challenge to The White Tiger.
Q: Please share an anecdote about something that happened to you as a consequence of winning the Booker.
A: In the Mumbai airport a few weeks ago, a woman recognized me from my photograph and said, "Your book has changed the way I see my servants." This wouldn't have happened if not for the Booker. It was one of the rare moments in the past few months when I've been glad that I won.
Friday, June 5, 2009
UPA II’s tokenism by a woman as President and as Speaker
JD (U) chief Sharad Yadav said Parliament
"We may not have the numbers but I will consume poison and die here but not allow the passage of the Women's Reservation Bill”………. "Congress party has been resorting to tokenism by appointing a woman as President and as Speaker,"
There is no such thing as “human rights”
Paul L Poirot argues very interestingly that “A man without property rights-without the right to the product of his own labor- is not a free man…..the real distinction is not between property rights and human rights, but between equality of protection from governmental compulsion on the one hand and demands for the exercise of such compulsion for the benefit of favored groups on the other”.
Professor Jagdish Bhagwati's on Chacha Manmohan Singh
Professor Jagdish Bhagwati's first take on the new Indian Government
I was asked to respond to questions about the Prime Minister and India's policies after the elections, by a well-known foreign journalist writing a story on this subject. Below are the complete questions and my answers which the journalist will quote from.
Q1. What, in your understanding, is Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's understanding of so-called "inclusive growth?"
Ans: He has always understood that the economic reforms which he started implementing wholeheartedly when he was Finance Minister would be the most important single change that would accelerate growth and finally reduce poverty, as indeed they have. This is "inclusive growth" indeed. This growth has directly pulled people out of poverty; it has also generated revenues without which little can be spent on bringing benefits such as health and education to the poor and the marginalized. The Prime Minister has always been explicit on these matters, criticising the critics of the reforms that fail to understanfd that, without growth and the accompanying growth of revenues, the "inclusive growth" that we planned for since the 1950s cannot be delivered.
Q2. Throughout his first term, Manmohan Singh was often criticized as weak, accused of being a puppet of Sonia Gandhi, and denigrated for caving in to the demands of the Left. Another Newsweek writer even blasted him for "missing his moment." In hindsight, it looks more like he was biding his time. Is he a natural compromiser, or was he simply a more savvy politician
than people gave him credit for?
ANS. The PM has had a strong partnership with Mrs. Sonia Gandhi who is the effective politician who has managed to turn the Congress Party back into a viable political party. But this "team" was shackled by having to work with rejectionist communist allies. Now that they are unshackled, we can expect that the PM will intensify the reforms which were largely on hold. Interestingly, Rahul Gandhi has also been emphasizing growth; and the post-1991 experience only underlines the fact that intensified economic reforms are the principal answer to our challenges.
Q3. One of the most interesting developments in the recent election was when Manmohan Singh began to respond directly to the charges leveled at him by LK Advani and others that he was a weak PM. What did you make of Singh's tough talk? Was that out of character?
ANS. In my long-standing experience with him since our days in Cambridge together fifty years ago, the PM has always displayed quiet strength of convictions and character, not the Oxbridge flamoyance. He is polite but no patsy. When Mr. Advani's criticisms got out of bounds, the PM responded firmly but without rancour.
Q4. There's a popular perception (though I'm not sure on what it is founded) that Manmohan Singh is a free marketeer, and Sonia Gandhi is the socialist /populist part of the equation. What's your assessment of Singh's opinion on issues like globalization, deregulation and the "religion of free trade?"
ANS. This contrast is only true in the sense that Mrs. Gandhi has to> cement and lead the Congress Party with its diverse elements and she has had to manage the alliance with anti-reformers like the communists, whereas the PM has to lead on policies. The PM, and indeed Mrs. Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi, are fully aware of how India has finally begun to have what Jawaharlal Nehru called our "tryst with destiny", only thanks to the reforms that included surmounting the fear of globalization and of freer trade; and that this has finally enabled us also to deliver on Mahtama Gandhi's vision of an India without poverty. They are unlikely to reverse course and return to the bankrupt policies of the pre-reform past to which the populists and ultra-leftists cling with impassioned nostalgia.
Thursday, June 4, 2009
Out of many, one
From Obama's speech to Muslims in
Indian babus most inefficient in Asia
"They are a power centre in their own right at both the national and state levels, and are extremely resistant to reform that affects them or the way they go about their duties," PERC concluded. "
Government is not part of the problem, it is the problem
Yes, T C A had believed actually other way around, thanks to his honest education.
Wednesday, June 3, 2009
Tuesday, June 2, 2009
Monday, June 1, 2009
Economics and Knowledge
Professor F A Hayek had disproved the existence of the notion of “equilibrium analysis” in his classic address to the London Economic Club; November 10 1936.

