Friday, January 9, 2009

Trade Doom of Hillary Clinton

In FT Professor Jagdish Bhagwati says “Mr Obama needs a stellar crew that will understand the protectionist nature of “fair trade” demands and dispel the unions’ baseless fear that trade with poor countries harms American workers’ wages.

Alas, his cabinet appointments include Mrs Clinton, whose trade scepticism is badly muddled at best, as secretary of state, and Hilda Solis, who reflects the anti-trade sentiments of the union federation, AFL-CIO, as labour secretary”.

 

Dilemma of Japan Economy

MC Shalom P. Hamou has commented on my post which I wholeheartedly subscribed from Christopher Lingle’s article published in Mint.   

First I agree with you in economics we should be a “straightforward to make the case that” will be relevant, rationale and unconventional in logic. 

It may not be true that the Japan economy is “constrained… by the inherent conservatism of a society that places so much value on consensus”. In fact I would say the post modern society monetary policy which has been emulated from the stymied political community of central bankers around the world. Indeed this community failed to sense what the giant F A Hayek wrote in "Choice of Currency”. 

It is absurdity to Say “the problems of the Japanese banking system, for example, can be interpreted as arising in part from the collision of a traditional, relationship-based financial system with the forces of globalization, deregulation, and technological innovation (Hoshi and Kashyap, forthcoming.” I wonder if the developed world says the same thing that developing world (although wrongly) breach in their home. Where the unconventional developments of post modern monetary society march? 

There is nothing to lose “traditional strengths” if the nation marches toward better living condition with core rule of law value.   

Politicians around the try to play “a major role in… macroeconomis” which is a fiction in practical life. 

Perhaps it is true that the political “the conventional wisdom that attributes much of Japan’s current dilemma to exceptionally poor monetary policy-making over the past fifteen years…”has broken the “the banking system”. 

A nation’s price of commodities and services is not an end product to “stabilizing aggregate demand and inflation” which is often deemed to be so. 

The biggest myth of twenty-first century will be the “responses,.. confused or inconsistent,  relied on various technical or legal” pundits in world.  

Back to Hayek read his choice of currency and his greatest theses of contribution to spontaneous economics. The problem of economics is not resources but information according to Hayek’s original contribution to economics. 

Finally it may be true that “A Credit Free (read choice of currency), Free Market economy is a solution that will correct all of those dysfunctions.”

Politics of Quadrilateral project

“One of the key reasons why infrastructure gets neglected, in the first place, is that there is very little political pay-off to filling potholes and repairing bridges, compared to spending that same money creating community centers, bike paths and other things” says economist Sowell. The BS editorial reports “the World Bank now has a report which speaks of huge delays, over-engineering of contracts, and a poor safety record during construction. The Bank now threatens to pull out hundreds of millions of dollars of commitments to NHDP projects.”

Thursday, January 8, 2009

Seminal Economics

T.C.A. Srinivasa-Raghavan just started column titled ‘Empty Sum’  The Business Line   Newspaper. He writes in his first piece: 

  • “Economists will protest, more than somewhat shrilly, that I am making far too many sweeping statements. That is to be expected. But, after spending a lifetime with them, I know that in their heart of hearts they agree that this is exactly true of most of post-war economics.
  • Techniques in econometrics have, of course, improved. But useful economic theory has made virtually no progress. Much of microeconomics stays where it was in, say, 1945, except in the matter of its dress. And as we are seeing now, macroeconomics hasn’t gone beyond Keynes, who published his seminal work in 1936.
  • My view is that the post-war period can be divided into two clear segments. The first comes roughly up to the mid-1970s when economic theory grew increasingly distant from real life and more-or-less merged into advanced mathematics. The second phase was a sort of reaction, and comprises the empiricist phase where, gradually, the mere presence of a data set has meant that anyone who knows a little regression can become an economist. Thought and thinking have both exited.
  • The trouble with empiricists, as opposed to empiricism whose importance can’t be denied, is that they can’t tell the difference between correlation and causality. I once wrote an article showing how every change of party of government in the US after 1945 has been accompanied by a recession.
  • The correlation was easy to establish but causation, in either direction, is another kettle of fish altogether. Even after having been advised early not to fall prey to it, they make the classic post hoc, ergo propter hoc (after this, therefore because of this) mistake.
  • The triumph of mindless empiricism has seen the advent of a menace called the policy economist. This tribe is to economics what ‘non-state actors’ are to security: guided missiles but with commercial intent. These economists flourish in think tanks which, if you ask me, are like those camps in Kandahar, Muridke, PoK, etc. But more about them in the months to come.
  • Overall, the swings between the two extremes — of economics posturing as physics so that it can use advanced mathematics, and data-based vacuity which has no roots in politics, custom, institutions, law, etc — have led the discipline into a state of meaningless tarkam and vitarkamwhere scoring petty points is mistaken for scholarship and where debate becomes an end in itself”.

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

The fiction of a liquidity trap

Christopher Lingle has excellent article in Mint particularly it is important to note the following: 

  • “In the current climate of global economic uncertainty, central bankers are creating vast amounts of paper money from thin air to pump into the global economy. 
  • central bankers are perpetrating and perpetuating the problems they claim to be seeking to avoid. 
  • In the current setting, interest rates in the US and Japan should be much higher than their present low levels at near zero. 
  • In other words, investment depends more upon spending rather than upon increased savings. 
  • As a modern proponent of the liquidity trap, Paul Krugman is as confused and confusing as Keynes. Krugman suggests that an economy caught in a liquidity trap will slide into deflation. But he then states that deflation can push an economy into a liquidity trap. Like Keynes, he seems to like to have it both ways”.

Whereas T.N. Srinivasan who is Samuel C. Park Jr. Professor of Economics at Yale University says “Unless the private sector sees the current slowdown as an essentially temporary phenomenon and believes that the economy will be bouncing back to 8.5 per cent or more [growth rates], simply reducing the interest rates will not help,” he said.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Directly pour money in the hands of people!

Kishore Biyani says: 

  • “The Chinese had drawn up a massive bill, largely funded by tax payers’, to be spent by the government itself in boosting the economic activity. Taiwan, on the other hand, decided to give back some money to its citizens to spend by themselves, thereby creating demand for products in local markets, which in turn could boost economic activity and job creation. 
  • Under a new policy announced in December 2008, the island’s 23 million people regardless of age or wealth were given 3,600 Taiwan dollars or around $165 as shopping vouchers. “The programme is aimed at boosting the economy and is expected to contribute to a 0.64% increase in 2009 GDP,” explained Premier Liu Chao-shiuan. 
  • The core belief behind this programme was government spending is not effective due to leakages and delay in execution, whereas private spending is far more efficient in boosting economic activity, creating demand for goods and services and raising employment levels. The idea of the voucher and stimulating growth through private consumption has been powerful enough for even the governments of Japan and Germany to consider such a move”.   

One of my Hero of economists ever lived in the world and in India was Professor B R Shenoy

Ashok V Desai who is no less senior living economist in India. He wrote a article in the Business Standard in 12 August, 1997 which I consider to be a biggest rubbish except or some of the following lines which I think worthwhile to remember a man of his age, great free market economist Professor B R Shenoy who lived not just an great human being but questioned the intellectuals of his counterpart mostly socialist babus. Anyway thanks to Desai for making me aware of his follies… 

  • “Returning to a legal definition of an Indian, the first patriot must be B R Shenoy. In my youth, Shenoy was a strident critic of policies; mainstream Indian economists treated him as an untouchable, and I must say that I myself took no serious interest in him then. But anyone who reads him today must see how right he was, for instance about inflation, controls, corruption, gold smuggling, planning or unemployment; everyone is experiencing it and saying it today. To be right is an achievement in itself, but to be right against the combined weight of establishment opinion, and to keep hammering at the truth regardless of consequences was foolhardiness of the highest order: that was patriotism”. 
  • “Jagdish Bhagwati is as affable as Bellicoth R J Shenoy was belligerent; but he is the next one on my list”.

Join the global baboos for making more mess

Chacha Manmohan Singh listed a group of people to “represents a vast untapped resource that can be harnessed as an input into national development processes in India”. 

See the below list: 

1)     Prof. Jagdish Bhagwati

2)     Sh. Karan F. Bilmoria

3)     Sh. Swadesh Chatterjee

4)     Ms. Ela Gandhi

5)     Sh. Rajat Gupta

6)     Dr. Renu Khator

7)     Lord Khalid Hameed

8)     Sh. Kishore Mahbubani 

9)     Sh. L.N.Mittal

10) Sh. PNC Menon

11) Ms. Indra K. Nooyi

12) Shri Bhikhu Chotalal Parekh 

13) Prof. C.K. Prahlad

14) Tan Sri Dato' Ajit Singh

15) Dr. Amartya Kr. Sen

16) Sh. Vikram Pandit

17) Sh. Sam Pitroda

18) Sh. Shashi Tharoor

19) Prof. Srinivasa SR Varadhan

20) Sh. Yusuf Ali, M.A.

 As it says that “the Council will serve as institutionalized dialogue mechanism between the diaspora community and the highest levels of Government”.

Manufacturing policy advisers

Yoginder K. Alagh says “Krishnamurthy is sadly an outlier, for his focus is all the time on doables, with examples from current policies of successfully industrialising countries. Sorry, my friend, the Maruti 800 was three decades ago. I still drive one, leaving the new fancy car to the lady of the house. But maybe you will have your day and we pray somebody out there is listening”.

A Nobel Low: Krugman Calls Small Government Philosophies Racist

Cord Blomquist asks: 

  • “How does Krugman attempt to do this?  First, he points to the G.O.P., as though Republicans are the vanguard of small government.  He claims that, “Forty years ago the G.O.P. decided, in effect, to make itself the party of racial backlash.” 
  • Mr. Krugman knows better and is hoping that smearing the philosophy of limited governement with accusations of racism will save him the work of presenting real, honest arguments against a very powerful set of ideas. 
  • Those powerful ideas were developed by philosophers and economists like Adam Smith, John Locke, John Stuart Mill, Friedrich Hayek, and Milton Friedman—giants of the academy. 
  • Hayek and Friedman especially must be known to Krugman.  Both were recipients of the same prize as Mr. Krugman, the Nobel Prize in Economics. 
  • Both were also more reasoned in their opinions than Mr. Krugman. 
  • Rather than dismissing ideas he disagrees with as racist, Mr. Krugman ought to get back to his academic roots and engage in a little constructive dialogue.  Perhaps that would prevent him from producing the the kind of thoughtless drivel he’s been allowed to publish in the New York Times”.

Saga folks on Das

Arun Venugopal says:

  • “There was a time--quite a long period, actually--when Westerners liked to refer to the "Hindu rate of growth" in India, i.e., the slow growth of the nation's economy (compared to other Asian countries) and its apparent basis in Hindu fatalism (Whaat to do, we're like that only). The term was supposedly coined by economist Raj Krishna but popularized by Robert McNamara. 
  • Atanu Dey thinks it should've been called "the Nehru rate of growth," to reflect its roots in socialist policies, but Arun Shourie had another idea in a column he wrote a year ago: simply re-brand "the Hindu rate of growth" as shorthand for high growth, and give credit to India's Hindus.
  • A couple days ago, "India Unbound" author Gurcharan Das wrote an op-ed in the New York Times. It's ostensibly about whether India or China will end up occupying the "top rung on the ladder of world power." Generally, I find these India vs. China discussions more a parlor game than anything else, but Das' larger point is that India manages to succeed despite its government, while China grows because of its government.
  • While he's at it, though, he can't help toss up a couple "Hindu" theories, explaining its economic growth as well as its democratic strengths.
  • The column has been received with some skepticism, namely the Vaishya theory, in an ongoing discussion on the SAJA discussion list (which is separate from this blog). But read Gurcharan Das' entire piece and let us know what you think”.

 Comments posted:

  • “It sounds ugly but Gurusharan das belongs to Khatri community, sub caste of Vaishya .He is some what right, when he claims -Indian economy is being ruled by Vaishya community.
  • when one community is identifiably superior to another in generating wealth (as you so APTLY point out) the heirarchy of caste must be reconfigured to give credit where it is due”.

Friday, January 2, 2009

Indian Liberals still doubt the natural trade

Gurcharan Das writes “India’s much-reviled caste system. Vaishyas, members of the merchant caste, who have learned over generations how to accumulate capital, give the nation a competitive advantage. Classical liberals may be right in thinking that commerce is a natural trait, but it helps if there is a devoted group of risk-taking entrepreneurs around to take advantage of the opportunity. Not surprisingly, Vaishyas still dominate the Forbes list of Indian billionaires”.

Thursday, January 1, 2009

Bureaucratization of government has increased

Vladimir Ryzhkov says when the government invented problems in “the country increase, the people will start demanding fundamental changes in the country’s political course and leadership”.

 

In fact Sauvik has greeted very well.

 

Who get easy access to ideas?

In there is a list of people who are influencing India in which it says that “India does not have easy points of reference for compiling a list, like a domestic Eton and Oxbridge (though Doon/Mayo and St Stephen’s might like to think otherwise), gentleman’s clubs (India International Centre may be a surrogate, but you cannot inherit membership there), and landed gentry (the only maharajahs who count are those in politics). And we used some key tests to whittle down from a long initial list, excluding those in high office today because that would be stating the obvious”.

In fact it further says “Then there are the grey eminences who have star power wherever they go, and who can help settle contentious issues (as APJ Abdul Kalam did on the nuclear deal, or Jyoti Basu). And people who wield power behind the scenes, while the Khan trio and sundry actresses traipse across the silver screen—film moghuls like Yash Chopra who would constitute the Establishment of the film world”.

Midst of an overriding out of the morass

T K Arun says in India invariably “All political parties depend, in the absence of institutional funding, on loot of the exchequer, patronage of vested interests and preying upon the citizenry to mobilise the resources needed to finance politics. The recent murder of a UP engineer is but an extreme consequence of the Indian mode of political funding. This, incidentally, suborns the officialdom and opens the path to bureaucratic corruption”.