Friday, December 12, 2008

Courage in venturing outside economics

Erik S. Reinert writes “Professor Krugman and the ancient Mexicans have something in common. Both made epochal discoveries, only to keep them as toy models instead of putting them to practical use. In my book How Rich Countries Got Rich…and Why Poor Countries Stay Poor, I refer to two important vices of the economics profession: what Schumpeter calls the Ricardian Vice, that is, the habit of piling a heavy load of strong policy recommendations upon very shaky assumptions; and what I have dubbed the Krugmanian Vice, the production of theoretical models that explain the real world better than Ricardo did – but not applying them to actual economic policy. In the third world the two vices combine to create serious obstacles to development.”

Much of the author’s clime or understanding seems politics theories of blaming or criticizing the government and its policies.  

Breeding politics of politicians but people have no deliberate choice out of socialist minds

It may be interesting to read these lines of great visionary Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan, on (August 14, 1947, in the Constituent Assembly) Indian “While India is attaining freedom, She is attaining it in a manner which does not produce joy in the hearts of people or a radiant smile on their faces. Some of those who were charged with the responsibility for the administration of this country, tried to accentuate communal consciousness and bring about the present result which is a logical outcome of the policies adopted by the lesser mind of Britain. But I would never ever blame them. Were we not victims, ready victims, so to say, of the separatist tendencies foisted on us? Should we not now correct our fault of character, our domestic despotism, our intolerance which has assumed the different forms of obscurantism of narrow mindedness, of superstition, bigotry? Others were able to play on our weakness because we had them. I would like, therefore, to take this opportunity to call for self examination, for a searching of heart”.

But politicians use all the Nobel ideas to brutalize the free society. 

Never satisfied

Nithyananda says in ET “Your life is a journey between birth and death. You have no idea why you were born. You have no idea when you will die. Your life is a bridge between these two unknown points. This is because you play with several pseudo identities, you have never asked yourself the question, who am I or what am I doing here?” 

The other massive trade journey

Mr Aiyar’s recent paper published in CATO institute says (excerpt published in BS) “Gujarat has pioneered the concept of port liberalisation in India and used this to become the country’s fastest-growing state. These results hold salutary lessons for other Indian states”.

 Also read my earlier post here

  

‘We choose butter rather than guns’ what economist can do?

Economist Bibek Debroy writes “Does an economy produce butter or guns? The UPA government’s choice was clear. It opted for butter rather than guns…”. Yet once again it seems that people are ready to choose “butter rather than guns” evidence from the recently held five state election of which three states voted for congress. 

However, let us note the terrorism trade “ndia may not be the country worst-affected by terrorist acts, but it has had its fair share in 2008 and December isn’t over yet. If one leaves out acts attributed to Maoists, there was Jaipur in May (63 dead, 213 injured), Bangalore (2 dead, 20 injured) and Ahmedabad in July (49 dead, 160 injured), Delhi in September (30 dead, 90 injured and 3 dead, 23 injured in a second incident), Gujarat and Maharashtra in September (8 dead, 30 injured), Agartala in October (4 dead, 100 injured), Guwahati in October (5 injured and 84 dead, 470 injured in a second incident), Srinagar in October (4 injured) and Mumbai in November (160 dead, 327 injured). There is a Worldwide Incidents Tracking System (WITS), with a broader definition of terrorism. Between 1 January 2004 and 30 June 2008, this database reports 4115 terrorist incidents for India. 4814 people were killed, 10658 injured and 2497 taken hostage. These figures are colossal and include less-visible incidents too”. 

But thanks to my friend Jayakamal who sent this article to me and don’t forget to read this excellent one by Economist Thomas Sowell who says “They didn't strike again here, even though they have struck in Spain, Indonesia, England and India, among other places. Does anyone imagine that this was because they didn't want to hit America again?”.

Monday, December 8, 2008

Change the Men and Ideas First?

Note the So called Liberal Mr Das 

I hate to read when people writes like this one by “Speaking of the global financial crisis, Sonia Gandhi recently applauded Indira Gandhi's bank nationalisation of 1969, saying that it had given India “stability and resilience”. Like the Bourbons of France, our political class neither learns nor forgets anything. I don't think Sonia Gandhi realises quite what she was saying.” 

It does not make sense if he says “I don't blame Nehru for adopting the wrong economic model as socialism was the wisdom of his age; I blame Indira for not reversing course as sensible countries in East and Southeast Asia did. Even China changed in 1978, but we had to wait till 1991. She multiplied by zero and put us back by a generation. ” 

If he don’t blame the Nehru folly ‘socialism’ who can blame then? There is no such thing as it is better to have lesser evil than the actual evil or the lesser evil is not revived the old evil.

It is once again that Mr Das mind losses the liberal idea.

Problem indeterminate: Freud, Marx and Darwin!

The ET column Jaideep Mishra some time attempt to shade the ideas and philosophy of economics with new muse, yet the present economic situation which push his mind to look back several years. 

Here are some from the recent article. 

  • The human, anthropogenic sciences have also had a similar transformation. A hundred years ago, a trio of big ideas — those of Freud, Marx and Darwin — held sway in the intellectual landscape. The ideas were no doubt intellectually seductive, proffering to theorise on the big ‘why’ of it all — of why we are as we are and not otherwise. Hence the essay to make sense of the here and now — Freud at the level of individuals, Marx that for whole societies and Darwin for all living things. 
  • Embedded in the thoughts, certainly in those of Freud and Marx, was the ‘promise of prediction’. The reasoning went that if this is how we traversed thus far, then that must be the way ahead; and if that is the way to go, then this surely is where we ought to be going anyway. 
  • There may well be a case for clear-cut financial innovation norms for orderly markets, but the seemingly loss of predictability in economics is the hallmark of all complex systems. 
  • The fact of the matter is that the role of prediction in economics involves a fundamental tension.

Noted the Point

When anybody says it is the economy, stupid I feel totally helpless to even to me. Because the economy is consist of individuals you and me, its not so? 

But Rama Bijapurkar writes in the ET “It is not the economy, stupid” . Who cares where the sensex is, when we have senselessness all around us. Who cares what kind of an economy we will be, if we are a battered nation, run by inept politicians or those obsessed with dynastic succession and / or vote bank politics?” 

Need genuine one or secular one

Meghnad Desai writes in the FE that “no doubt honestly serving the people in their own humble ways. I don’t even mind their corruption, if they would only deliver the simplest public goods. But no such luck. What is to be done?” 

This is how corruption is granted like “take it easy” by an economists of this country. 

But it must be noted when he says “There is no political party today which is both genuinely secular and sound on economics. Swatantra was there in the sixties and seventies but was cannibalised by Janata and BJP. India badly needs a right of centre political party which will do what is needed—ensure a government which is at least a good nightwatchman. 

No party has commanded a majority of those voting, let alone the electorate since independence. Still governments claim that they have a mandate, to flout the constitution and abridge fundamental rights in the name of some flimsy ideology of socialism. Indira Gandhi laid the foundations of this tragedy by her arbitrary rule. Let us have proportional representation and strict limits on executive power as exists all over continental Europe”.

Who has failed us?

They have failed us writes Rajiv Desai in TOI “The political class is like the public sector, which seeks to run a modern enterprise in a bureaucratic fashion. Politicians and bureaucrats and their cohorts try to operate a modern nation state with command and control techniques more suited to the colonial era. ”

The mantra of entrepreneurship development

Some people need no introduction in a country. In India, Mr N R Narayana Murthy is one of them. 

He says five important things to development oneself: 

  • “First of all, entrepreneurship is all about converting an idea into wealth, jobs, products and services. Therefore, if an idea has to succeed in the market, the business value of the idea must be expressible in a simple sentence, not a complex or a compound one.
  • In other words, it should do one or more of the following unambiguously: reduce cost; reduce cycle time; improve productivity; enhance customer base; and enhance customer comfort. Unless the idea is able to do any of these better than existing products and services do, it is unlikely to succeed. Of course, once in a while, entrepreneurs come out with an idea that creates discontinuity in the marketplace like automobile, television or computers. But it does not happen very often. Most often, a new entrepreneur improves existing products and services incrementally. 
  • Second, the market must be ready for that idea. No matter how good the idea or the value proposition is, if the market does not perceive value, the idea will fail. There are many such cases. Therefore, the success of an idea depends on how well the value proposition of the idea is accepted by the market. 
  • Third, you need a team of people with mutually exclusive but collectively exhaustive skills, expertise and experience. Many entrepreneurial ventures failed because they brought people with just similar skills — technologists, sales people or finance people together. These days, venture capitalists use the key-employee network to bring in additional expertise for an entrepreneur. It is ideal if an entrepreneur can put together such a team. 
  • Fourth, you need an enduring value system because, in the initial stages, entrepreneurship is all about hard work, courage, deferred gratification and sacrifice. Otherwise, the group will not succeed. In fact, I have seen that the most crucial reason why most start-ups fail, other than the market acceptability, is the incompatible value system among the members of the initial start-up team. 
  • Finally, of course, you need money. Fortunately, that is easier today than when we founded Infosys. Today, there is lot of venture money chasing good ideas”.

Economists Vested Interests

Crisis of understanding of economics and Arvind Panagariya’s bad economics. 

Why “Thanks to the former RBI governor, Dr Y V Reddy, India almost entirely escaped the devastation of the financial sector wrought by the crisis in countries such as Korea. The finance ministry, while paralysed on numerous urgent Main Street reforms, has been actively pushing for deregulation in the financial sector”. If India was escaped why the folly is giving stimulus package to boost the economy? 

Keeping interest rate highest in the world is the great achievement by Y V Reddy!

After 1947

Two point agenda of Ajay Shah 

It may be true to argue “The police are often more dangerous than the criminals, so many crimes go unreported”. But it is utterly debatable issue that “the brute fact is that in most parts of India, women were safer going out after dark under British rule than they are today”.

However, it is the need of the hour that “For India's development to proceed, we need to greatly shift the focus of the State away from welfare programs to law and order”.  

Dr Manmohan Singh Should learn from Professor F A Hayek

Doug French writes “Hayek explains, "such complex phenomena as the market, which depends on the actions of many individuals, all the circumstances which will determine the outcome of a process...will hardly ever be fully known or measurable. …..the government’s moneymen are engaging in what Hayek referred to as "the fatal conceit," thinking they have the knowledge to fix and plan the economy. They can and will only make matters worse”.

Delhi based Liberty Institute won “Atlas Shrugged Grant”

Atlas Shrugged Grant Recipients