Saturday, December 6, 2008

The expert is the ‘Problem’

I have been reading Mr KRISHNA KUMAR articles for quite some time but this one is no exception. He seldom says government or institutional failure the utter that should be instead of accepting “lesser evil”. 

The real question one should ask is “good vs evil” not lesser evils. See few Paragraphs below:

  • The kind of teacher that the NCF demands needs to be given time and resources to study and reflect on her or his own practice and on the world surrounding the school. 
  • This is the kind of teacher that the new NCF-based syllabus and textbooks require. The new textbooks are based on the premise that children learn from many sources, not just textbooks. It is expected that teachers will share this premise, not merely in principle, but in practice too, in the sense that they will actively look for non-textbook sources of knowledge and also recognize as valid the sources that children might locate out of their own desire to learn. 
  • .....market forces have grabbed the teacher education sector, treating it as a source of money….. 
  • India will have a few million teachers who enjoy being teachers of the young and deserve to be respected by the adult society. In the interim, we might have to choose between a lesser evil and continued kitsch and chaos, and essentially focus on training teachers to resist the temptation and systemic pressure to give up all higher goals for the sake of marks. 

Knowledge is Pretence

Professor F A Hayek said in his Nobel lecture “As a profession, economists have made a mess of things……... If man is not to do more harm than good in his efforts to improve the social order, he will have to learn that in this, as in all other fields where essential complexity of an organized kind prevails, he cannot acquire the full knowledge which would make mastery of the events possible. He will therefore have to use what knowledge he can achieve, not to shape the results as the craftsman shapes his handiwork, but rather to cultivate a growth by providing the appropriate environment, in the manner in which the gardener does this for his plants. There is danger in the exuberant feeling of ever-growing power which the advance of the physical sciences has engendered and which tempts man to try, "dizzy with success," to use a characteristic phrase of early communism, to subject not only our natural but also our human environment to the control of a human will. The recognition of the insuperable limits to his knowledge ought indeed to teach the student of society a lesson of humility which should guard him against becoming an accomplice in men's fatal striving to control society — a striving which makes him not only a tyrant over his fellows, but which may well make him the destroyer of a civilization which no brain has designed but which has grown from the free efforts of millions of individuals".

 

The electorate might

M K Venu writes in the ET  “This is an opportunity for both the BJP and the Congress”. It may be stupid, to tell people that this is an opportunity for political parties to clime votes to do good things. Shout the mouth, the real opportunity comes to people once in five years but bad politicians have been continuously getting this just opportunity to ruin the people’s basic freedom. 

 Is that the opportunity we are all ready to give it to the politicians hand?

Friday, December 5, 2008

Economics of awakening

One thing we as individual tends to forget always is the “We have been going above the government, below the government or around the government, but we never really engaged with the government.” 

It is not the fault of the same individual but it is for every reason the government or state or the welfare state, stupid, theft hard earning of individual you and me and forget the purpose for which it promise to theft from us. Now, it becomes enemy of us by its own virtue. But one may is there any virtue out of government. 

How horrible the government we all know when we try to remember the “Last week in Mumbai”. Don’t tell me next.

“Tehzeeb ki kami hai”

T. C. A. Srinivasa-Raghavan writing is always s mixed veg curry one could taste in different way. Is all that good to tease one’s actions when he comes to public office?  Here are few lines from his recent article in the Business Line. 

  • “Left to himself he would have balanced the Budget but he served Sonia Gandhi a bit too well and allowed the fiscal deficit to go up to around 10 per cent when you take into account the off-budget tricks he played. 
  • one should ask him the question: politics may impose compulsions on a minister but does it also impose compulsions on the soul?”  

May be good question but never be a wrong time.

 

The other!!!! Which is peard hunky dory?

Srivatsa Krishna writes in ET : 

  • …the finest financial brains and watched over by who one thought were prudent and experienced regulators, suddenly sputter to a dead halt?  
  • …..a karmic coincidence, one of the key proponents of it later in the SEC is one of the current bosses of the American treasury! 
  • …..fancy mathematics PhDs hired by various Wall Street giants created more and more sophisticated models to try and justify lending to those who were inherently not creditworthy, it started a race to the bottom. Evidence of this is the fact that in 2002 on the average, private equity firms were on a 4x leverage multiple which grew dramatically to almost 6.5x in 2008!.... 
  • …..the last week of September, 40 billion of seven-day treasury bills were sold, at a yield of 1/20th of 1%! 
  • At the time of the Great Depression the total credit market debt/US GDP ratio stood at about 270% whereas today it’s at about 350%! Over the past 10 decades of the previous century this ratio has stood at 200% or below. 
  • …where anyone could walk in and make a bet on any stock, without actually purchasing anything! This was the precursor to the Great Depression of 1907. 
  • ….the size of the credit default swaps market was $100 billion. It stands at a staggering $60 trillion in 2008!  

Only the reader can hunch if (s) he have been reading all kind of opinions on the current financial crisis.

Vote bank means middle class but all politicians are top class not by virtue

Abhinav Kumar is a police officer and writes the length and breath of the Indian police system. Especially after every incident that happened the present one focuses on law makers and their expertise, resources allocation, etc. the below are notable. 

  • …..out of the 25 odd officers of joint secretary rank and above in the ministry of home affairs (MHA), only two of them are professional police officers with any field experience, and their real influence on policy making is debatable. Other nerve centres of the decision making structure, namely the PMO and the cabinet secretariat are equally bereft of professional internal security expertise. 
  • As a policeman, I cannot help but feel growing rage and anger at the repeated assaults on the idea of India. If Mumbai 26/11 is able to create a national mood for effecting the changes outlined above in a time bound manner, it would be the most apt tribute to all the innocents who lost their lives. Otherwise it would be business as usual.

My reading at 12.18 Am!!

Anarchic capitalism vs. sensible capitalism by Prabhudev Konana, The Hindu. 

It is important to note a few paragraphs from Konana piece. 

  • “The perfect storm of incompetent management, dogmatic unions, and imprudent regulations on bio fuel and mileage standards has now resulted in an economic nightmare. 
  • Still sensible free-market capitalism is the most desirable system for wealth and job creation. While many, including me, have criticised India’s growth in the last two decades as one-sided development, the fact remains that millions of new jobs — some of which are very high-paying jobs — were created. There is passion and excitement among the educated class. It is disingenuous to assume that liberalisation and free-market principles are bad. However, any criticism should be on the government’s heavy handedness in violating the private property rights of farmers, heavily subsidising industries, and excessive preference to some sectors while ignoring infrastructure and neglecting education and healthcare for the underprivileged sectors. 
  • There is a role for the government to facilitate economic activities with sensible regulations. Regulations play two important roles within a capitalistic system.  
  • The economic ideologues at the extremes are harmful to any nation. India’s potential was trapped for decades by intense protectionism. Capitalism has unlocked that potential and is still the best path to prosperity”. 

The law is made by gathering some narrow view about individual citizen of country-one size fits all. These law makers are often stupidly called experts in government. What sensible law one can expect from these lawmakers who themselves think they are the big law for even one - BIG Government?

Thanks to Tucker!

Jeffrey A. Tucker writes “In light of the present crises, and the appalling ignorance of the present generation of policy makers of any historical understanding, it is so helpful to remember that we've been down this road before, and done all the wrong things before. Forget learning from history. The present generation does even know enough history to learn anything from it. So this interview really makes it clear what has come before”. 

This is F.A. Hayek in 1975 on Meet the Press also quite interesting to listen. 

Myth of welfare state

Since the political independence what we are seeing in India is the “Great Society functions as a great boon and benefit to the poor; in reality, when we cut through the frothy appearances to the cold reality underneath, the poor are the major victims of the welfare state. The poor are the ones to be conscripted to fight and die at literally slave wages in the Great Society's imperial wars. The poor are the ones to lose their homes to the bulldozer of urban renewal”, (The Great Society: A Libertarian Critique by Murray N. Rothbard).

Who owns whose Time!

Mr Aiyar’s writes in his 2006 article: 

  • Having long wooed criminals, it is only a matter of time before more political parties start wooing terrorist outfits too. 
  • The problem is that India's judicial system is so slow it often seems that criminals are more likely to die of old age than be convicted. 

Individuals only own their time not society. When it comes to the judicial system everything is owned by judges and politicians nothing is called public law which is equal to every citizen of country. 

Liberal Economist Sauvik once wrote in TOI that the fifth factor of production in the economics is the ‘Time’ which is the most precise than anything else. 

The other three factor of production is here.

 

Beat constable and Beat Box?

Chandigarh may be famous for many but it is one thing that needs to mention here is the “Beat Box”. Every police station will have at least one ‘Beat Box’ or near by. I once asked a person. When I asked him why police have beat box? He said if the small traders, dhabas, petty shops etc are finds not holding of license to trade or to put small shop over there he will be put in the Beat Box!   

Mythili Bhusnurmath has already written in ET “How many times? How many more lives?” 

The rationale behind true rule of law in these two cases remains same.

Learn from Gujarat…

Swaminathan S. Anklesaria Aiyar says in his new A Case study from India in Cato Institute.   

  • Gujarat has broken new ground with different forms of privatization, ranging from private provision of port services to completely private ownership of new ports. 
  • Gujarat’s port liberalization, along with its status as one of the economically freest states in India, should serve as a model for the rest of India and other developing countries, which can also benefit from the dynamic gains of port privatization.

Back to blog!

One of the radical liberal economist and friend Sauvik asked in this blog why this blog has been silent for some time. 

Actually, I was planning to write few lines about the week that went by Mumbai’s Terrorists attacks and the public funded National Security agencies who were counting the deaths day and nights. The other thing I wanted to write about my last week field visits. I went with two objectives one is to find out the impact of modern technology in agriculture and its access to small and marginal farmers in India. The other one is that whether these modern technologies are affordable to the small and marginal farmers. I will answer these two questions later. 

So I had little time to read articles and comments etc and also the unavailability of internet connectivity in the field visits.