Saturday, November 15, 2008

At last the Novel

Ajit Balakrishnan says in BS “if the famous Greenspan ‘put’ is at the heart of the crisis, blame it on the faith in unbridled free enterprise he inherited from Ayn Rand”.

But one has to go long way to understand what he says further that the “Atlas Shrugged epitomised Ayn Rand’s faith in an unbridled free enterprise system; the belief that the clear separation of the economy and state was as central to human progress as the separation of the church and the state had been in an earlier era. And the belief that any form of state intervention in society is fatally flawed and would lead to stagnation”.

 

Brave new questions but not as Brave!

Ajit Balakrishnan writes in BS “Greenspan never saw how derivatives would make the housing crisis a global one”. 

But other questions are equally important but not so plausible;

 “Why did, then, Warren Buffett, whose financial acumen is legendary, describe them recently as “weapons of mass destruction”? Where did they come from and how did they become such objects of veneration as well as hate? 

The mathematical model they came up with, the Black-Scholes model, did its job of pricing options so well that Gladstein made tons of money using it, Merton and Scholes won the Nobel Prize in Economics for it, and started the rush of mathematicians to the stock market. 

Derivatives are a way to “hedge” against these risks. For example, a housing loan to a borrower in, say, Cochin can be combined with a housing loan in Mumbai and another one in Bangalore under one common instrument and this combined “derivative” can be sold to an investor. This combination reduces the risk of disparate housing markets such as Cochin, Mumbai and Bangalore all suffering downturns at the same time. The investor in this derivative rightly believes that the instrument he holds has a balanced risk.    

If derivatives can diversify risk, as just described, what can go wrong? 

When Greenspan, who was Chairman of the US Federal Reserve Board, was told about similar issues developing in the US mortgage securities market he believed that such problems in the housing sector would be restricted to a city and could never become a national, let alone an international problem.” 

Surjit S Bhalla expansion

Surjit S Bhalla asks few questions in BS that the starter has to think and do home works to get answer so consider some of them; 

“…..when everyone has been proven wrong, let us assess what some of the maestros have said, and done. Internationally, the clever people were baying for Bernanke's blood, stating that it was a huge mistake to not let Bear Stearns fail; a mistake because of the principle of moral hazard (didn't you know that Wall Street does not learn a lesson when 95 percent of its wealth is wiped out?). 

This "intellectual" non-market pressure was an important component in the US Fed making its first mistake through this financial crisis which started in August 2007 — and what a mistake it has been. It has brought not only the US but the international banking system down. Jobs, and not necessarily of those belonging to Wall Street, are being lost by the millions, and growth is negative. What price moral hazard? I can't help thinking, and believing, that a market participant would never have advocated the arrogant bureaucratic/academic demand for letting Lehman fail. 

It was less than two months ago that several non-market experts were claiming that the RBI was way behind the curve; eg Ajay Shah argued for more monetary tightening, in September, because the highest interest rates in the world were too low to combat imported inflation! (Wall Street Journal Online, Sept 2, 2008). Others echoed with similar sentiments. This was near universal conventional wisdom of leading investment firms, policy makers, pink paper experts, business TV anchor, academics — is there anyone left? If these gentlepersons were in the market, they would readily admit that they were horribly wrong.  

As of October ’08, the consensus was that India would have a double digit fiscal deficit, and that the oil deficit would account for 2 to 3 percent of GDP. But all of the fundamentalists (the moral hazard, monetary and fiscal, RBI/MoF and the IMF types!) were also forecasting a global growth slowdown of historic proportions. The fundamentalists forgot to note that low world growth, and WTI oil price below $65 for the Oct ’08-March ’09 period would mean an off-budget contribution of the oil deficit to be close to zero percent of GDP”.

How to win the Nobel prize by a whisker

Tim Harford writes in FT few fascinating analytics see some of those below: 

“The Nobel memorial prize in economics is typically awarded to researchers who have jointly advanced some important method or idea. When the 2008 prize was awarded to Paul Krugman alone, for his contributions to trade theory and economic geography, other candidates who might have shared the prize – but didn’t – must have counted themselves one small step further away from receiving the call from Stockholm.    

Among them are Jagdish Bhagwati, Krugman’s teacher and champion, and a giant in the field of international trade; and Elhanan Helpman, who wrote an influential book with Krugman on the new trade theory. 

Economies of scale push towards larger and larger companies. Logically, a monopolist should be the lower-cost provider. The tension between economies of scale and competition is obvious. 

Yet while obvious, it is hard to model mathematically in a useful way. Dixit and Stiglitz resolved the problem by observing that consumers have a taste for variety as well as a taste for low prices. In the market for cars, for instance, Volvos compete with Fords and Ferraris. It would be cheaper if there was only one model of car; it would be nicer if there was an infinite variety. Somewhere in the middle is the equilibrium where economies of scale are balanced by customers’ desire for variety. 

The elegant mathematics of the Dixit-Stiglitz model was new, even if the tension it described was as old as Smith’s Wealth of Nations. Krugman described it is as “beautiful”. It quickly became a workhorse, pulling economists to new frontiers of trade theory, growth theory and economic geography. Dixit later said he and Stiglitz had not realised the model would have so many uses – “obviously, otherwise we would have written all those subsequent papers ourselves!” 

That is typically generous of a man who has often praised others, especially Krugman. He once told young economists that a good place to have ideas was in front of the shaving mirror. Krugman has a beard. Imagine, quipped Dixit, how much he could have achieved if he shaved!” 

Friday, November 14, 2008

Revisit your changed mind

The Mint column Mr Niranjan Rajadhyaksha writes “The second old-new issue that may be discussed this weekend is how to rebalance the world economy. Economists had noted the dichotomy at least six years ago—and warned that it is a threat to global economic stability. In short, the US spends too much and saves too little while China spends too little and saves too much. This fault line was papered over by capital flows. China ran up a huge trade surplus with the US—thanks to an undervalued exchange rate—then sent the dollars thus earned back into the US, which kept interest rates there low and allowed American consumers to borrow further to buy from China”.

He would have written three years ago about the thread not after the dog comes to eat away the meal. And how far the decisive mind allows him to say nations should ‘rebalance’ it must be noted here that the individual only can balance their plan not the nation!

Subir Roy orthodoxy mind

Mr Roy writes in the BS “The Indian central bank was never totally independent and should not be. In ordinary times monetary and fiscal authorities have to maintain macro-economic stability and, in exceptional times, have to break as many rules as they need to in order to maintain social stability”.

Of course there are many more anomalies in his analysis about India and the world economy

The Rich get Poorer is any one talking about it?

Robert J. Samuelson says some important discussion about how rich get poorer and instead the poor get poorer. Consider the following arguments;

“By and large, the poor aren't poor because the rich are rich. They're usually poor for their own reasons: family breakdown, low skills, destructive personal habits and plain bad luck.

The presumption implicit in the criticism of growing economic inequality is that society's income is a given and, if the rich have less, others will have more. Up to a point, that's true.

The government already redistributes much income, often for the good. During the boom years, companies might have been less lavish with top executives and slightly more generous to other workers or shareholders. Some new fortunes stem from self-dealing and financial razzle-dazzle, not the creation of real economic value. It's just deserts that some of this wealth has evaporated.

But the redistributionist argument is at best a half-truth. The larger truth is that much of the income of the rich and well-to-do comes from what they do. If they stop doing it, then the income and wealth vanish. No one gets it. It can't be redistributed because it doesn't exist. Everyone's poorer.

Scapegoating and punishing all of the rich won't do us any good if the resulting taxes dull investment and risk-taking, discouraging economic growth that benefits everyone”.

It is a tail that wags the entire subcontinent

This teases out the canine tales — of mythical Sarama, telegenic pugs and more

Mr Nehru Beautiful kids have great Minds don’t ruin them!

Today is the Children’s Day as the usual climes are not new Mr Jawaharlal Nehru Birthday and the birth of Central Planning Commission to Ruin in Stroke!

But for many children this day is also death day as the first Prime Minister of India damaged the Indian Children’s Plan by creating socialist pattern of society and the Central Planning Commission of India.

The below is my song to the Great Children’s Community. This song is added from borrowing the first lines from Usha Jesudasan in the HINDU Young World.

There are beautiful expressions in this Young World but muddled idea of Nehru finds room in fact Sauvik has already done good job!

On Children’s Day, let’s think about what you can do to help other children in India; because the Planning Commission of India can not plan for your future!

On your way to school, you may see lots of little children who do not go to school; because the Planning Commission of India can neither plan nor provide sufficiently!

Do you turn your face away from them? Don’t do that; because the Planning Commission of India will never take care of those children’s!

Remember that these children are just like you, but poor; because the Planning Commission of India planned and ruined for more than sixty years and still does what they think and whom to distribute instead leave to you and me to plan for out life!

And on this special day we need to think about them too; because the Planning Commission of India will never think even after sixty years of central planning!

Perhaps as children you feel that you are too young to do anything; because the Planning Commission of India made your parents to think they are too old to fight for second revolution of individual freedom!

That is not true; because the Planning Commission of India is deep sleep let’s awake yourself with the help of your fellow students!

As a child you have a well of goodness and kindness inside you; because the Planning Commission of India does not have and you know that when you grow up to face the difficulty being created by this Planning Commission of India!

Rabari, a small shepherd boy, used to take his family’s goats up the mountain for food; because the Planning Commission of India does not know how to distribute the food!

His mother would pack him a few dry rotis, some pickle and if he was lucky, some vegetable or dhal.

As he walked through the streets with his goats, he saw hungry children working on building sites; because the Planning Commission of India planned for their own children’s and multiplied by six decades!

He felt sad for them as they never had enough food; because the Planning Commission of India eaten the big folly of AID from Foreign Countries!

So, he would come down from the mountain at lunch time and share his food with them; because the Planning Commission of India will never give single rupee to live but whatever they have will ruin by taxes!

He wished he could have done more for them; because the Planning Commission of India will never think of a small share for these children’s!

But he did what his heart told him to do; because the Planning Commission of India can never plan to teach people know how!

If you listen to your heart and do what it tells you to do, your well of goodness too will never dry up; because the Planning Commission of India will never tell these things that individual people know what is good for you!

Perhaps this year, you and your family can make a collection of sweets and give them to street children and talk to them about Children’s Day? Because the Planning Commission of India will never do any good things to people no matter you pays the taxes!

What does Barack Obama's election mean to you?

Raina Kelley in Newsweek wrote “A Letter to My Son On Election Night” perhaps one has to think especially the parents when they give advice to their children not only during the election time but always.

I enjoyed the article especially these lines “I can mean it when I tell you that the world is available to you……. you have to work and work hard” . I have posted the same article below for the future use.

“What does Barack Obama's election mean to you? It means many things. When you are older, we will talk about how African-American children, like their parents and grandparents, have struggled to overcome the feeling that no matter how hard they study and work and try, there are barriers—some visible, others hidden but still there—that block their way. The feeling that we can rise, but only so far. I did not want you to grow up believing that bitter remnants of the past could hold power over your future. I wanted to be able tell you that it wasn't true—that you could be anything you wanted to be. But I couldn't quite believe it myself. Now I do.

With Obama's election, I can mean it when I tell you that the world is available to you. Yes, I am waxing a bit emotional, so let me temper my exuberance. No election can wipe away racism, and bigotry will show itself to you in ways subtle and not. But it is easier today than it was yesterday to see that racism, once a barrier, is now more like a hurdle. What a fine new addition I have to my mother's arsenal of aphorisms: Son, I can (and probably will) say to you, Barack Obama faced hurdles but succeeded, and you can, too. You are only 4 months old, but already I dream of what a great rocket scientist you'd be. But if you want to be a cattle wrangler, that's OK, too. And if you want to be president? Well, we'll talk.

If you do become president, it won't be just because you won the votes of people who look like you. This election was such a triumph because it tested our nation's fundamental promise of equality—and we as a nation passed. Black Americans did not elect Obama. Americans did. Even if every African-American in the country had voted for him, it would not have been enough. He will enter the White House with the support and good wishes of millions of people of all races, colors and creeds.

Yet this break from the hold of the past, this hope of greater expectations for ourselves, comes with greater expectations on ourselves. We can no longer look to blame outside forces for our failures or rest our shortcomings in the cold comfort of bigotry. If you want to be like Obama, you have to work and work hard. He went to Columbia University and Harvard Law School. He traveled the world and opened his mind. He did not simply dream of being president; he summoned the discipline to get there.

If you could understand any of this, you'd be rolling your eyes at me right now. Hey, I was a kid, too, and it's easy to skip out on homework when no one is looking. But I speak from experience. In eighth grade, I made a contract with myself: I was going to Yale. I drew up a list of everything I would need to do to get in. It wasn't easy; I got C's in chemistry and physics and nearly failed gym (don't laugh—you inherited my genes). But the acceptance letter came.
I worked hard in college and graduated. Along the way, there were plenty of people who doubted me and said unkind things, and not all of them were white. Your black classmates might see you reading a book at recess or raising your hand in class and call you "too white" or "Uncle Tom." Ignore them. Don't let them mess with your mind or steer you from your goals. All of us have to defy stereotypes. Don't be afraid to let go of any part of our color that holds you back. As your grandfather says, "be proud and the black will take care of itself." Too many African-Americans are obsessed with rickety notions of what "real" black people do or don't do. I've been guilty of it myself, and I've been accused of being too white most of my life. Your dad is white, which means technically you are biracial—but that's black in America. I leave that for you to figure out. For now just understand that your race is part of who you are, but it isn't all of who you are. If anyone doubts your "authenticity," you can tell them that you want to be as black as the man behind the desk in the Oval Office”.

Way forward is OK Show me the Route

JNU Professor Manoj Pant asks in ET probably GOOG questions yet still in Keynes ilk dynasty. Consider his questions;
“Are we in for four to five years of bad times as in the ‘thirties and how important is the US to the solution?
Second, what role can India and China play in any recovery?”
Any one heard the following joke at least as of now.
“The usual argument is that the US was living beyond its means as reflected in its huge and growing trade deficits. (One has been hearing this at least since 2000!)

The main problem in unilateral trade protectionism is that it is then extremely irrational for any one country to reverse protectionism: only multilateralism works.

The Great Depression shifted focus from the Commonwealth countries to the US. Will the next shift be to Asia? Is India ready? Only time will tell”.

However the last two paragraphs may not be a joke but debatable one.

“Raffle and Skills Contest”- A solution to present US Financial Crisis

Steven Kurutz observed a good solution to the present financial crisis in US and other countries. The following two important observations need to be noted:

“Desperate, Crawford came up with a novel strategy: she would hold a raffle. Tickets would go for $100 each, and one lucky person would win the farmhouse. If they could sell enough tickets, they could walk away debt-free”.

Last December, the couple teamed up with a real estate agent and a local charity, and set about publicising the raffle, posting flyers and calling news outlets. By the time the draw was held at a local country club this March, they had sold almost 6,500 tickets, raising enough money to cover the cost of the house along with a surplus of more than $200,000 that went to the charity. Having already moved back to the log house, they counted themselves lucky to still have a place to live. "We were so happy, because we’d gone on this horrific two-year journey," Crawford said.

Others, though, are finding creative ways around the rules. Julie Sigwart, a Web designer, is holding what she calls a "skills contest" to give away her six-bedroom, four-bathroom house with ocean views in Maui, Hawaii, which she has been trying to sell since last October.

As in the raffle for Crawford and Kelly’s home, she will charge a $100 entry fee, but participants will have to write an essay—the theme is "Aloha, what does it mean to you?"—which will be judged by a group of "prominent members of the community," she said. (The judges have yet to be finalised.) Because the contest isn’t a game of chance, state approval is not required, and teaming with a non-profit organisation isn’t necessary”.

The Loss Of Individual Liberty

Peter Robinson writes in Forbes “All that the nation's founders understood two centuries ago about the imperative of limited government, all that we learned from the long struggle between collectivism and free markets during our own time--all this could soon simply evanesce”.

Before this conclusion he also wrote “Academia as a whole may have continued its long, sorry wobble to the left, I continued, but the economics profession had proved an exception, moving the other way. Departments of economics across the country now grasped the importance of free markets. "Mises, Hayek, Stigler and you," I told Friedman. "You've transformed the intellectual climate. You've won."

Friedman shook his head. "We may have won the intellectual battle," he replied, "but in practical politics, it's difficult to see that we've had any effect at all."

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

Shameful legacy

Kaushik Basu writes in the Outlook (Why) “..tax the rich more and subsidise the poor” if that is the case, the revive of government created slavery which is a government funded death penalty will amount to cascade rather to enrich the ‘poor’. Best example is the malfunctioning India’s subsidy system. It is sad that Mr Basu has paid little attention to this big issue. And in once sense it is not surprise to see because he is also student of Mr Sen. 

However, he concludes that “that Obama spoke about redistributing wealth. I do not think he will be able to do much in this area, but if such a call from an American president causes a shift in public opinion, that could well clear the way for a more equitable and better world. ”     

Lack of belief in freedom= lack of life, liberty and property.

As Milton Friedman put it, "A major source of objection to a free economy is precisely that it ... gives people what they want instead of what a particular group thinks they ought to want. Underlying most arguments against the free market is a lack of belief in freedom itself. "

Is from the Corner Nationalreview