Wednesday, November 12, 2008

Why couldn’t the theories predict the current crisis?

Manas Chakravarty writes in the Mint “Is something seriously wrong with economics? After being cold-shouldered by the model-building, regression-fitting economist fraternity for long, Keynesian and other less orthodox economists are getting a bit of their own back”.

Not surprisingly what I find from his following paragraph was loathingly fallacy that is he writes “In an interview to The New York Times, economist James Galbraith, who has steadfastly stayed loyal to the liberal theories of his celebrated father John Kenneth Galbraith, said that the failure to foresee the mortgage crisis was “an enormous blot on the reputation of the profession”. He went on to say: “There are thousands of economists. Most of them teach. And most of them teach a theoretical framework that has been shown to be fundamentally useless.”

He also says that “he policies currently being implemented by Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke and his ilk. In a speech in 2002 at a conference to honour economist Milton Friedman’s 90th birthday, Bernanke said: “Regarding the Great Depression. You’re right, we did it. We’re very sorry. But thanks to you, we won’t do it again.” He was referring to a famous book on the Great Depression by Friedman and Anna Schwartz which essentially said that the depression was the result of mistakes committed by the monetary authorities of the time. Said Bernanke, “Because of institutional changes and misguided doctrines, the banking panics of the Great Contraction were much more severe and widespread than would have normally occurred during a downturn…” Bernanke has been a scholar of the Great Depression and his present policy of throwing vast amounts of liquidity at banks and recapitalizing them is based on the premise that not doing so in time is what allowed the crash of 1929 to morph into the Great Depression”.

Manas not only report misleadingly but make reader confused. Of course, I ma not but let’s grasp the An Open Letter to my Friends on the Left by Professor Steven Horwitz.

Tuesday, November 11, 2008

Who spend how much?

"Democrats are indeed big spenders. Second only to the Republicans" says Veronique de Rugy in Reason.

India and the G-20 Washington summit

Yele University Professor T.N. Srinivasan suggests some of the following ideas that India may consider in the forthcoming Group of 20 Countries meeting on the issues of present financial crisis.

  • The most important reforms in my view would be first to restrict the mandate by the IMF to maintaining the stability of the global financial system with the definition of the financial broadened to include the fiscal, monetary and exchange policies as well as global markets for trading financial claims. The involvement of the IMF in the largely domestic policies of its developing country members which have no cross-border externalities through its insistence of the Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers from those seeking its assistance should be stopped forthwith. India should strongly advocate both these reforms. 
  • It is likely that the summiteers may not be able to resist pressures to discuss regulatory reform and, in particular, the boundary between regulation and markets. Such a discussion can be meaningful only after we have an adequate analysis and understanding of the relative contribution of failures of each to the current crisis. In its absence, I would urge India not to take an ideological posture on the issue but to simply emphasise that it would be counterproductive to suggest a “one size fits all approach.” Instead, the search should be for a solution that leaves adequate and appropriate room for markets and regulation. Another reform issue that should be postponed for a later occasion is the reform of the World Bank. It certainly is in need of a significant downsizing and restriction of its engagement through its lending and free policy advice only to those countries for which external resource and policy making capacity are serious constraints on development. There is no rationale any longer for the Bank to be lending, for example, to Brazil, China or India. All three should be charged a fee for the Bank’s advice if they seek it.

Opportunity for true leadership

V S Mahesh writes quite interestingly in BS: the below paragraphs are really notable;  

  • In the event of bankruptcy, the president will forfeit all his private assets to the creditors of the company. In his book, Hasegawa cites the case of the President of Kojin, whose palatial residence in Denenchofu was handed over to the creditors of the company when Kojin went bankrupt. 
  • the top management earn much more than the lowest wage earner in a company in good times, they are the ones who take the first blows when the times go bad. Top management will normally cut their salaries, followed by the next layers in strict sequence and only finally, will the lowest wage earners be asked if they too would volunteer to reduce their salaries. 
  • The secret behind their success was that they had done what the Japanese would have done. First, their top management cut down their salaries by 50 per cent, then the administrative officials responsible for the production division cut down their salaries by 35 to 40 per cent, and only then was the income of the hourly staff cut down by 20 to 25 per cent. Not a single employee was retrenched. That the entire organization had jointly tightened their belt and seen the crisis through as a cohesive team should be obvious to anyone. This was in California and not Japan! (For more on this, readers can refer to my book, Thresholds of Motivation, Tata McGraw-Hill, 1993). 
  • In the Taj Group, we knew that we were in for a bad year. Rather than taking the axe out to cut employee force, we did something quite different. We ran “cost-reduction” workshops in all hotels, where employees were asked to come up with suggestions on how to cut waste and unnecessary costs. We assured them that in the best traditions of the Tatas, we would try our very best to jointly cope with the crisis and did not threaten them with mass retrenchment. Employees responded with literally thousands of suggestions and we rode the storm jointly and came out much stronger as a team when the crisis ended. In one hotel, we cut food costs by 10 per cent, largely because of suggestions that came from the lowest rungs of the kitchen staff.

Best minds gravitated

Best minds yet to come in new India!

According to B S Raghavan “A census taken in the late 1990s revealed that of the 468 law colleges existing in the country then, teacher per institution average was 2.38 which is less than half of even the feeble five full-time teacher per institution prescribed by the Bar Council. As regards the quality of teaching, the less said the better”.

UNILATERAL DISAGREEMENT

While reviewing the Jagdish Bhagwati’s new book (SUSTAININGINDIA’S GROWTH MIRACLE) Bibek Debroy writes in Indian Express “t is a tragedy that this year’s Nobel Prize wasn’t shared by Paul Krugman with his former teacher Jagdish Bhagwati. Krugman’s work on strategic trade theory has sometimes been interpreted as justification for state intervention in free trade flows. In contrast, Bhagwati’s work is for unabashed free trade and against protectionism. How does one ensure free trade and removal of barriers?” 

However “Bhagwati’s book only prescribes part of the medicine. But on the prescription given, there is no better popular book I can think of.”

See my other post on the same book review here  

B.R. Shenoy: stature and impact

Bauer, Peter Bauer had written this great work and published by Cato Institute Journal in 1998

B.R. Shenoy: stature and impact

Article Abstract:

Indian economist B.R. Shenoy gained his greatest distinction from his paper 'Note of Dissent' and the book 'Problems of Indian Economic Development. The former was attached to Second Five Year Economic Plan submitted to Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru in 1956. It demonstrated the extent of his moral courage in that he dared to declare a dissenting view on the traditional Western economic perceptions and beliefs held by Nehru at the height of the latter's powers. He pointed out the weakness of an economic forecast that bases its growth on the productivity of people living on subsistence levels.

Book Review

C.T. KURIEN reviewed the new book on SUSTAINING INDIA’S GROWTH MIRACLE Edited by Jagdish N. Bhagwati, Charles W. Calomiris

The following are the key ideas suggested by authors:

Arvind Panagariy: Comparing the growth profiles of China and India, Panagariya points out that in the former, capital flow was into unskilled/labour-intensive industries which helped the country to become a major supplier of light industry goods to the rest of the world. 

…..suggests that if foreign capital is to move into unskilled/labour-intensive industrial segments in India, now dominated by the informal sector, some drastic changes in labour legislation favouring foreign capital are called for.

T.N.Srinivasan: The first is to create a Fiscal Review Council, partly to replace the periodic Finance Commission, but mainly to provide a forum for the Centre and the states to discuss each other’s fiscal policies in a common forum.

…..the second, to convert the Planning Commission into a Fund for Public Investment is questionable as it perceives the role of the Planning Commission solely as a funding body.

Changed or he changed

M K Venu says in ET “a closer examination of the situation might reveal that facts may not be changing as quickly as being projected. The universe of market players, analysts and economists just see what they want to see”. In this case John Maynard Keynes famous quip will permanently dead in the long run. But we live, not surely with that mind change!

 

Stiglitz is No Mockery!

Joseph E Stiglitz says “America exported its deregulatory free market philosophy”.

It is blunder to accept anything and everything without the minding of the business of the business in our life from other persons or from other countries in the world. It is the same in the Stiglitz case too.

Ten Blunders in Communism

Robert Higgs writes “the list of ten measures that Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels presented in the Manifesto of the Communist Party as "pretty generally applicable" for the establishment of communism "in the most advanced countries."

 I reproduce the same ten blunders below:

  1.  Abolition of property in land and application of all rents of land to public purposes.
  2. A heavy progressive or graduated income tax.
  3. Abolition of all right of inheritance.
  4. Confiscation of the property of all emigrants and rebels.
  5. Centralization of credit in the hands of the state, by means of a national bank with state capital and an exclusive monopoly.
  6. Centralization of the means of communication and transport in the hands of the state.
  7. Extension of factories and instruments of production owned by the state; the bringing into cultivation of waste lands, and the improvement of the soil generally in accordance with a common plan.
  8. Equal obligation of all to work. Establishment of industrial armies, especially for agriculture.
  9. Combination of agriculture with manufacturing industries; gradual abolition of the distinction between towns and country, by a more equable distribution of the population over the country.
  10. Free education for all children in public schools. Abolition of child factory labor in its present form. Combination of education with industrial production, etc.

Economist Ajay Shah is back on firing RBI Actions

How to control the Inflation Tiger? Ajay Shah gives many interesting suggestion. The below are the few which are really need of the hour. If fact, I would expect a 15-20 percent rupee appreciation. So that I can able bye things which I wanted to buy from foreign countries. Of course millions of people would buy things like that and this. 

  •  The way forward lies in breaking the rupee/dollar peg, as was done in early 2007, and having a 10% rupee appreciation. 
  • We are suffering from these problems because of the blunders of monetary policy. The possibility of such blunders needs to be eliminated by rewriting the RBI Act. The text of this Act is completely wrong in the light of the monetary economics that we know today. With a sound monetary policy framework, inflation would be stabilised, inflation crises like this would not periodically hijack the government, and distortionary short-sighted initiatives such as banning exports of certain goods would not arise.
  • The right combination of policy for the short term involves (a) an appreciation to Rs 36 per dollar with (b) a reduction in the short rate to 4%. 
  • A 10% rupee appreciation would yield a nice dent on inflation, as happened in March 2007. 
But finally I got the Adam Smith famous Book of “Wealth of Nations” from US through my friend. 

Monday, November 10, 2008

Of Obama & Martin Luther King

Of Obama & Martin Luther King

The above poem is written in Tamil and Translated into English!

Demise of liberals in India....

I have been reading about the so called Indian liberals writings (both as individuals and organizations). What was quite interesting was that many of them were moved beyond the belief of the ‘liberal idea’ particularly with the victory of US elect President Obama election.

But it is not surprise but happy to note what Sauvik Chakraverti writes in the Indefenceofliberty that the “….. this year's Nobel prize in Economics, awarded to Paul Krugman, whom I consider to be a dangerous Keynesian. And there are others like me. If we did not have the freedom to criticize this award, if the Nobel prize was awarded by a "ministry of truth," all dissenting voices would be stifled”. 

Obama's most protectionist rhetoric

Barack Obama's victory with many war words but the prophet of "Yes, we can" is a one which is now matter than the before US election at least for India.

See Swaminathan S A Aiyar article in ET it may sound you against Obama’s future promise but we have to think the root causes keeping in mind the below some of key paragraphs:

“Now that the US is slumping into the worst recession since 1979, can Obama take measures to reduce the outsourcing of software and business services to India, and reduce visas to Indian software engineers? Yes, he can. 

Can he take measures to reduce the flow of direct and portfolio investment to India? Yes he can. He wants to raise the capital gains tax from 15% to 20%. That worsens the risk-reward ratio for US investors, and will make them more reluctant to invest in emerging markets like India, which are considered riskier than the US. 

Can Obama devise tax and other measures that will penalise US companies that invest abroad, in countries like India, rather than in the US? Yes, he can. 

Can Obama come out with protectionist measures to shift jobs from poor countries to the US? He not only can, he has promised to do so. 

Can he increase subsidies for and compulsory use of corn-based ethanol, measures that have caused a big spike in world food and fertiliser crisis? Yes, he can. 

Can he kill the Doha Round of the World Trade Organisation by taking a much tougher line than Bush on keeping US farm subsidies high? Yes, he can. 

Can he act against
India for building up its forex reserves, and hence keeping the rupee weaker than it would otherwise have been? Yes, he can. He has in the past voted to penalise China for doing just this. In the current financial crisis it is wise for Third World countries to keep high forex reserves, but this is not recognised by protectionists in the US. 

He has said that if only the Kashmir issue is settled, Pakistan can better concentrate on al-Qaida and the Taliban. The Indo-US nuclear deal is through. But can Obama come up with hurdles on details, like licences for dual-purpose technology? We hope not, but yes, he can. His supporters include non-proliferators who still want to punish India. 

Can he insist that India should enact a law limiting the liability of US nuclear suppliers in the event of an accident at an Indian nuclear power plant? Can he urge India to sign an international convention shifting liability from equipment suppliers to the company running a nuclear plant? Yes, he can. 

Here again, we must not exaggerate the risks. In practice,
US policy may not change much. But history shows that Indo-US relations have usually been better under Republican than Democratic presidents. Democrats are more protectionist, and tougher on nuclear non-proliferation. 

Bill Clinton was personally popular in
India, but never did anything for us except impose sanctions after Pokharan II. Bush was personally unpopular in India, yet did us yeoman service by pushing through the nuclear deal. Can Obama do anything to match that? Yes, he can, but I rather doubt that he will”.