Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Nations are built by healthy institutions

Mr Pratap Bhanu Mehta wrote in his resignation letter to PM “Why should all institutions in a country the size of India adopt the same admissions quotas? Is there no room at all for different institutions experimenting with different kinds of affirmative action policies that are most appropriate for their pedagogical mission? How will institutions feel empowered?............... how will they ever achieve excellence and autonomy if basic decisions like who they should teach, what they should teach, how much they should charge are uniformly mandated by government diktat?............. grave dangers for India as a nation… continues to abet a politics of illusion.”.

“Jawaharlal Nehru. He wrote, “So these external props, as I may call them, the reservations of seats and the rest, may possibly be helpful occasionally, but they produce a false sense of political relation, a false sense of strength, and, ultimately therefore, they are not so nearly important as real educational, cultural and economic advance which gives them inner strength to face any difficulty or opponent.”

Tale of teacher absenteeism lies in Teachers Union

It is absurd to argue that the “evaluation of teachers can wait”. Of course “there’s a lot that is wrong in the education sector in India, be it at the primary or higher education level”. In General the Indian education system has been sucked out of good quality education. The unionized teacher group is major part of the damages.

In fact it is not true that “there is every chance that they could be victimised” supposes if that is the case is not that the children are now victimized in schools, colleges and the universities? They are.

What importantly Adam Smith said was that “the teachers had no jurisdiction over their pupils, nor any other authority besides that natural authority, which superior virtue and abilities never fail to procure from young people towards those who are entrusted with any part of their education.”

Every marginal buyers increase risk into the market

Raghuram Rajan writes in the India Today “Essentially, the US financial sector managed to package mortgages to low-credit quality buyers and issued highly rated securities against these packages that foreign investors were willing to buy. They were putting lipstick on a pig. And hindsight suggests these were still pigs”.

Interestingly he writes that “I spoke to central bankers in August 2005, at Greenspan's farewell Jackson Hole conference, about the increasing risks in the financial system. A number of people were worried, but regulators were convinced that markets would take care of themselves”.

If the regulators were convinced wrongly about the market the problems is with regulators not necessarily on market.

What are the lessons for India?

India Whining story

Odd academicians, economists particularly the pro reform economists got fed up with usual complaints in economics and occasionally visit book review by biting mixed words.

Professor Bibek Debroy writes in Business Today that “The Indian Renaissance is more anecdotal and less pedantic and places change in a broader sociocultural-civilisational setting. “However, there is nothing inevitable about India’s rise. Demographic change and growing literacy are but enabling factors. In the end, what matters is that India has the confidence to take advantage of the opportunity. This calls for a mental attitude that requires to be actively promoted. Human history is full of civilisational dead-ends and India’s own history shows how things can unravel. The decline of Kolkata, the city of my birth, should serve as a warning that even the most cosmopolitan of societies can lose their way.”

And not surprisingly “since most pending reform areas are state subjects. There is a point to the India Whining story, except that it misinterprets symptoms and prescribes wrong cures, having mis-diagnosed the disease. Any book on the Indian economy that doesn’t address these issues is likely to be accused of being pro-urban and elitist.”

The 2008 Nobel Prize Bet

Bet on the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences at PinnacleSports.com

Teacher deserve peanuts!

I was taught some of top economic professors in Tamil Nadu in Madras University but not even one qualifies to call a true teacher unfortunately had one in my schooling.

Take for example a professor taught about Swedish economist Gunnar Myrdal’s “Asian Drama” and other ideas but utterly did not mentioned not eve once about F A Hayek.

What is special about these two economists is that both were awarded Nobel Price in Economics in 1974!

Secondly, another professor taught economic development and planning but never hinted about B R Shenoy’s Dissent Note to the Second Five Year Plan of India.

Third a professor asked student to tell something about Karl Marx theories. “Marx said only how to capture a country but did not say anything about how to govern” I said the Marxist professor said “you don’t know anything sit down!”

What Sauvik Chakraverti wrote was “Teacher! Don't teach nonsense”

Now “what do you think your teachers deserve? A real debate at least?”

Sure peanuts for my teachers I don’t know about your teachers!

Games in School without Parents Role

Thomas Sowell writes that “A real reformer would want to crack down on both unruly students and unaccountable teachers. A clever politician would speak eloquently, demand "change"— and then vote for the status quo. Obama talks a great game”.

But F A Hayek something called “Game of Catallaxy” which is nowhere in Indian schools.

Max Speciality, a shocking death!

Mint report that “A person familiar with the situation said Bhuyan had been admitted for a triple bypass heart surgery. There was, he said, an error with the tubes when Bhuyan was hooked to the heart-lung machine. Instead of the tube that transports blood, a tube supplying compressed oxygen was inserted into his aorta. “The doctors and technicians realized their mistake in seconds but he died of an overdose of oxygen,” he added. He did not want to be identified”.

There cannot be a free market for land

Sauvik Chakraverti has an excellent article in Mint on “The original sinners of Singur” See other post here

Pity New IIT!

The Economic Times editorial “notes that IIT-Rajasthan classes have begun on the IIT- Kanpur campus but that lecturers are sometimes greeted with empty classrooms. It’s not because the IIT-Rajasthan students are playing truant. With eight to 10 students crammed into each accommodation meant for an IIT-Kanpur faculty member and with only one bathroom, the students are either missing classes or arriving late. IIT-Kanpur never had to maintain an attendance register. However, the attendance for IIT-Rajasthan has been so abysmal that the IIT-Kanpur director has asked instructors to record the students’ presence or absence on a regular basis. If you’re wondering why the IIT-Kanpur director has to issue such directions, it’s because he is the acting head of IIT-Rajasthan!”

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Gandhi died Jinnah lives!

When it comes to the notion of disobedience to the outsider (ruler) is it that the notion also gets eliminated when the outsiders moves out?

May not be so it is also possible to counterproductive that is what happened and happening in India.

Mr Harihar Narayanaswamy writes in the Economic Times that “Interestingly, there were some who predicted this outcome even at the time that Gandhi first adopted these methods. The most notable opponent to Gandhi’s civil disobedience tactics was Mohammad Ali Jinnah way back in the 1920s, who believed that the path to independence lay in constitutional methods. In fact, the use of such tactics by Gandhi (which Jinnah often equated with political terrorism) was one of the sticking points in their relationship. Jinnah argued that independence if won through such methods would be counterproductive: “Your extreme programme for the moment has struck the imagination mostly of the inexperienced youth and the ignorant and illiterate. All this means disorganisation and chaos”.

"You Can't Blink"

I like the “you can’t Blink" Poetry of Sarah Palin

"You Can't Blink"

You can't blink. You have to be wired In a way of being So committed to the mission,The mission that we're on, Reform of this country, And victory in the war, You can't blink.
So I didn't blink.
(To C. Gibson, ABC News, Sept. 11, 2008)

India uncut Amit Verma likes "Outside"

Think Tank Solution

Parth J Shah solution to Indian school education:

“Problem: The nexus between Bollywood and the underworld. Mahesh Bhatt for example borrows money from Dawood Ibrahim to make his films.

Policy Solution: Declare Bollywood as an "industry" so it can access credit from financial institutions.

Problem: Long queues for school admissions, high fees and demands for donations.
Policy Solution: Remove the license raj in education (as we did in industry), allow for-profit schools, declare education an industry so that budget private schools could borrow to improve and expand”.

Muscles of Developed Country-USA and Japan

The Nobel Prize in Physics 2008

2008 Nobel Prize for AIDS

The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 2008