Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Poor knew how to escape from Poverty

Here is a book review by BIBEK DEBROY on “Out of Poverty” by Paul Polak.

It is worth to note that “He has written, and has been written about. But this is his first book. “I hate books about poverty that make you feel guilty, as well as dry, academic ones that put you to sleep. Working to alleviate poverty is a lively, exciting field capable of generating new hope and inspiration, not feelings of gloom and doom. Learning the truth about poverty generates disruptive innovations capable of enriching the lives of rich people even more than those of poor people.” This is not an academic and dry book. It is part autobiographical, partly about IDE and mostly about the poor and how their lives were transformed. It is anecdotal, and written in a style impossible to describe in a review. Without any qualification, this is a book everyone should read”.

And “Says Polak, “The most important poverty eradication myth is that we can donate people out of poverty. Incredibly, Jeffrey Sachs, head of the UN Millennium Development Goals Initiative, believes that people who live on a dollar a day are too poor to invest their own money to move out of poverty… But this type of subsidy solution is endemic in the development world... To move out of poverty, poor people have to invest their own time and money. The path out of poverty lies in releasing the energy of Third World entrepreneurs.”

See my other post here

The idea

In the Economist, leaders article says that the “Ideas should not be suppressed, but nor should they be worshipped……. there is no sure defence against bad ideas, but one place to start is with a well-educated and sceptical citizenry that is free to listen to the notions of the intellectuals but is not in thrall to them—and, yes, may prefer the sports channel instead.”.

Now any one can imagine how socialist and communists talks about idea in India and why they are against any reforms in education, healthcare etc.

Hardly Facts Matter

Prominent liberal economist Thomas Sowell writes in Townhall that the “the future of this country, as well as the fate of the Western world, depends on how many people can be fooled on election day, just a few weeks from now.”

What people need never get but what politician need will get certainly

“Abraham Lincoln said, "You can fool all the people some of the time and some of the people all the time, but you can't fool all the people all the time."

But I will not “laugh or cry”

The fifth column Tavleen Singh says that “Half of India's children are malnourished, more than half of Indian women suffer from aneamia, we have one of the highest rates of infant mortality in the world and most deaths of children under the age of five are from preventable diseases. Can we afford to worry about smoking in public places?”

Further “the two things they need more than anything else are access to decent pubic healthcare and decent schools. It is scandalous that the Indian state has been unable to provide these two most important tools of empowerment and if you examine why you will discover that it is because we have our policies and priorities all muddled up”.

“One of the legacies of our dark decades of Nehruvian socialism is our ability to waste taxpayers' money on make believe public utilities”.

Her usual writing hits at 360 degree calices but “half-built sheds without teachers or books that we call schools. Crumbling, empty buildings that we call hospitals. Poles stuck in fields for electricity and rusty hand pumps that we pass off as water supply. The Health Minister now forces us to spend a few thousand crores more on trying to enforce a ban that may improve the personal health of a few heavy smokers but will do nothing to improve public health.”
Is that the ban is relevant or the need of the hour?

Socialist Murky

What made this murky socialist Indian who wanted to see the deep darkness?

Gurcharan Das in his column in TOI said that “our socialists were impatient, and one sad day in 1978, the Janata government removed ‘property’ from the list of fundamental rights in our Constitution”.

Further he writes “Clearly, the state violated the farmers’ right to property when it forcibly acquired their land”. Now who will ask to whom?

See other posts 1 2

The Marx-Hayek message

It is not new to compare between any two extreme economist but yet it need to be seriously think through.

Meghnad Desai writes in Financial Express “They were schooled in Hayek and as libertarians, they believe that in a free market there should be no handouts and no free lunches”….. Hayek took the stark view that cycles were natural to capitalism and arose from a tendency to resort to cheap money which, in turn, led to mal-investments and then a crisis which had to 'detox' the system . He was against any rescue and any premature reflation. In the 1930s, no one took any notice of Hayek and Keynes with his much softer approach to capitalism won the day. But Keynesian demand management ran into its own crisis after 25 years of full employment—the Golden Age of Keynesianism lasted from 1945 to 1970.
But there is an anomaly saying that J M Keynes was approached “much softer way to capitalism”.

It may be the fact that in many parts of the world “What killed it was a classic Marxian 'falling rate of profit' crisis”. But it also true the neo classic Marxian killed far more amount of people.

Monday, October 6, 2008

How much information can have government to plan and plead?

Mr. Easterly is professor of economics at New York University writes in WSJ “We will never know. But we do know that the free market has a long-run track record of creating prosperity -- even with the occasional crash. The Depression's deceptive intellectual legacy is that development flows from all-knowing states rather than creative individuals. Here's hoping that the backlash to today's crash will not spawn another round of bad economics for the poor”.

I have no idea how many of you are listening.

“F” grade for Economics Nobel laureate

Usually F means fail but it can also used fallacy when the particular notion has been misguided like one by Mr Joseph Stiglitz a Columbia University professor, who himself won the 2001 Nobel Economics Prize.

GMU economist writes in Cafehayek “I'd give an "F" to any of my undergraduate students who would make such a fundamental mistake as the one made here by Stiglitz”.

It is absurd to believe what Stiglitz says “I think, the crisis is leading to a fundamental change in the philosophy. We’ve seen that unfettered markets can be a disaster”.

Does he think that the government is the soul solution to problem like financial crisis, when it created this sort of disaster?

Is $US is ugly

Is it really the $US is ugly in the world, may be or may not be so. May be because it is called in fact used as “the dollar is the international reserve currency” and “this is the root cause of our present problems” if it is may not be because “during the past few years was built on loose US monetary policy that kept interest rates unrealistically low and allowed US consumers to live beyond their means”.

Read more “The good, the abd and the ugly” by Mythili Bhusnurmath an Economic Times Columns.

Friday, October 3, 2008

Running Economists

Many people started predicting about this year Nobel Prize for Economics. As it starts from Indian born Prof Jagdish Natwarlal Bhagwati, has been nominated for the Economics Nobel for more than nine times. Then Prof Avinash Kamalakar Dixit and Prof Partha Sarathi Dasgupta.

As I posted earlier here.

See more 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

F A Hayek’s Road to Serfdom

Thomas W. Hazlett interviewed Professor F A Hayek in 1992.

“Sometimes you have to live a long time just to be proved right. When Friedrich August von Hayek, born in 1899, died March 23 in Freiberg, Germany, he had outlived both Keynes and Marx. Happily for the human race, so have his ideas.

[Contributing Editor Thomas W. Hazlett interviewed Hayek in 1977, shortly before starting graduate school in economics at the University of California, Los Angeles.]

Reason: Of your bestselling The Road to Serfdom, John Maynard Keynes wrote: "In my opinion it is a grand book.... Morally and philosophically I find myself in agree- ment with virtually the whole of it: and not only in agreement with it, but in deeply moved agreement." Why would Keynes say this about a volume that was deeply critical of the Keynesian viewpoint?

 

Hayek: Because he believed that he was fundamentally still a classical English liberal and wasn't quite aware of how far he had moved away from it. His basic ideas were still those of individual freedom. He did not think systematically enough to see the conflicts. He was, in a sense, corrupted by political necessity. His famous phrase about, "in the long run we're all dead," is a verv good illustration of being constrained by what is now politicallv possible. He stopped thinking about what, in the long run, is desirable. For that reason, I think it will turn out that he will not be a maker of long-run opinion, and his ideas were of a fashion which, fortunately, is now passing away”.

 

One has to have an open mind to accept honestly other side of thinking like one by J M Keynes! But not his followers at least as of now.

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

Make free trade to work

Christopher Hayes writes in the New Republic that the Mainstream economists reconsider globalization!

“Economies do best when they specialize in producing the goods and services they can make most efficiently and trade for those goods outside their specialization”

This is what simple economists are arguing time and again. 

This is what simple economists are arguing time and again. Prominent trade Economist “Jagdish Bhagwati is a humble man. He will tell you so himself”

Stealing is the soul business of Government

From tomorrow onwards the existing and potentials smoker’s freedom will be prohibited throughout. I knew some people who can’t simply live without a smoking.

There is news in FT which says “There is no provision of smoking rooms in public places”. What a nasty.

And it mentions “As many as 600m people here are below 30 years of age. We consider them as the high-risk group when it comes to tobacco, alcohol, drugs use, HIV infection and junk food consumption,” Mr Ramadoss said recently.

   

Ustaad, Mureed, Gurukul, Shishya

Mr Manish Sabharwal’s elegant writings are more like a new technology which not only cut through the costs but make sense to think particularly on skill development.

Here is the “Learning While Earning” in which interestingly writes “apprenticeship learning. Professions like doctors, chartered accountants and lawyers have mandatory apprenticeships. Research shows that apprenticeships account for 70% of competence development in many countries. So, why is the powerful train of apprenticeships for skill development still stuck at the station in India?”

I am thinking for some time why there is no optional or mandatory apprenticeship for subjects like economics in Indian colleges and universities in which most of the post graduate and doctorate students pass out without a sense of other economic systems like Austrian Economics or free market economics.

This article draw several questions which needs urgent attention but the fact is “Today’s problems start with a regulatory framework that is fractured between the Directorate General of Employment and Training (DGET) of the ministry of labour, the ministry of human resource development and State Apprenticeship advisers. The partition between a graduate and trade apprenticeship is artificial and exists only in the cerebral cortex of regulators”.

And the “Critics say this is a misallocation and waste of government money but isn’t this better than a 90 day job under NREGA? If not anything, it puts youth into a corridor for permanent jobs with the improved employability that comes from experience”.

Economic Nightmare is the pioneer of Made in India

John Templeton said that “the government of India regulates nearly everything, so there's very little progress; whereas in Hong Kong the government keeps its hands off . . . and the standard of living has multiplied”.

Mark Skousen wrote in 2002 that “the mutual fund magnate John Templeton traveled around the world during the 1930s, noting in particular the extreme poverty in two Asian nations under British control, India and Hong Kong. Forty years later, in the 1970s, Templeton returned. Once again he witnessed the incredible poverty in India. But Hong Kong had changed tremendously. "The standard of living in Hong Kong had multiplied more than tenfold in forty years, while the standard of living in Calcutta has improved hardly at all”.