Friday, October 3, 2008

Running Economists

Many people started predicting about this year Nobel Prize for Economics. As it starts from Indian born Prof Jagdish Natwarlal Bhagwati, has been nominated for the Economics Nobel for more than nine times. Then Prof Avinash Kamalakar Dixit and Prof Partha Sarathi Dasgupta.

As I posted earlier here.

See more 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

F A Hayek’s Road to Serfdom

Thomas W. Hazlett interviewed Professor F A Hayek in 1992.

“Sometimes you have to live a long time just to be proved right. When Friedrich August von Hayek, born in 1899, died March 23 in Freiberg, Germany, he had outlived both Keynes and Marx. Happily for the human race, so have his ideas.

[Contributing Editor Thomas W. Hazlett interviewed Hayek in 1977, shortly before starting graduate school in economics at the University of California, Los Angeles.]

Reason: Of your bestselling The Road to Serfdom, John Maynard Keynes wrote: "In my opinion it is a grand book.... Morally and philosophically I find myself in agree- ment with virtually the whole of it: and not only in agreement with it, but in deeply moved agreement." Why would Keynes say this about a volume that was deeply critical of the Keynesian viewpoint?

 

Hayek: Because he believed that he was fundamentally still a classical English liberal and wasn't quite aware of how far he had moved away from it. His basic ideas were still those of individual freedom. He did not think systematically enough to see the conflicts. He was, in a sense, corrupted by political necessity. His famous phrase about, "in the long run we're all dead," is a verv good illustration of being constrained by what is now politicallv possible. He stopped thinking about what, in the long run, is desirable. For that reason, I think it will turn out that he will not be a maker of long-run opinion, and his ideas were of a fashion which, fortunately, is now passing away”.

 

One has to have an open mind to accept honestly other side of thinking like one by J M Keynes! But not his followers at least as of now.

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

Make free trade to work

Christopher Hayes writes in the New Republic that the Mainstream economists reconsider globalization!

“Economies do best when they specialize in producing the goods and services they can make most efficiently and trade for those goods outside their specialization”

This is what simple economists are arguing time and again. 

This is what simple economists are arguing time and again. Prominent trade Economist “Jagdish Bhagwati is a humble man. He will tell you so himself”

Stealing is the soul business of Government

From tomorrow onwards the existing and potentials smoker’s freedom will be prohibited throughout. I knew some people who can’t simply live without a smoking.

There is news in FT which says “There is no provision of smoking rooms in public places”. What a nasty.

And it mentions “As many as 600m people here are below 30 years of age. We consider them as the high-risk group when it comes to tobacco, alcohol, drugs use, HIV infection and junk food consumption,” Mr Ramadoss said recently.

   

Ustaad, Mureed, Gurukul, Shishya

Mr Manish Sabharwal’s elegant writings are more like a new technology which not only cut through the costs but make sense to think particularly on skill development.

Here is the “Learning While Earning” in which interestingly writes “apprenticeship learning. Professions like doctors, chartered accountants and lawyers have mandatory apprenticeships. Research shows that apprenticeships account for 70% of competence development in many countries. So, why is the powerful train of apprenticeships for skill development still stuck at the station in India?”

I am thinking for some time why there is no optional or mandatory apprenticeship for subjects like economics in Indian colleges and universities in which most of the post graduate and doctorate students pass out without a sense of other economic systems like Austrian Economics or free market economics.

This article draw several questions which needs urgent attention but the fact is “Today’s problems start with a regulatory framework that is fractured between the Directorate General of Employment and Training (DGET) of the ministry of labour, the ministry of human resource development and State Apprenticeship advisers. The partition between a graduate and trade apprenticeship is artificial and exists only in the cerebral cortex of regulators”.

And the “Critics say this is a misallocation and waste of government money but isn’t this better than a 90 day job under NREGA? If not anything, it puts youth into a corridor for permanent jobs with the improved employability that comes from experience”.

Economic Nightmare is the pioneer of Made in India

John Templeton said that “the government of India regulates nearly everything, so there's very little progress; whereas in Hong Kong the government keeps its hands off . . . and the standard of living has multiplied”.

Mark Skousen wrote in 2002 that “the mutual fund magnate John Templeton traveled around the world during the 1930s, noting in particular the extreme poverty in two Asian nations under British control, India and Hong Kong. Forty years later, in the 1970s, Templeton returned. Once again he witnessed the incredible poverty in India. But Hong Kong had changed tremendously. "The standard of living in Hong Kong had multiplied more than tenfold in forty years, while the standard of living in Calcutta has improved hardly at all”.

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Autonomy is must

Whether it is colleges or universities and institutions even schools need the ingredient of autonomy both financially and professionally.

S P Parashar writes “History has shown that all recommendations of such committees will never be accepted by the government”.

Thanks for governments for wasting taxpayer’s money for appointing committees after committees.

 

The dream is good but we have to wait and see how beast government acts

Mr V RAGHUNATHAN writes in the Economic Times “I recall waiting for somebody in Beijing once for 20 minutes on a street and during this short interval, saw one wall of a whole floor of a building rising up, as the cranes moved huge pre-fabricated blocks in place incessantly. May be, that is why in the time that it took Bangalore to build its Indira Nagar flyover, Beijing got ready for the entire Olympics”

Less the power more the effective IAS but doubtful

Allow me to take brief curse of this article by Sameer Sharma in Economic Times.

“What do IAS officers do?” they do ruin the taxpayers money to their home of course there are few who do less ruin but it is a ruin! In Economic terms it is killing millions of people life.

“The most common normative guide is found in the rational decision-making model, which starts with goal identification based on a known singular public interest, followed by listing of all possible alternatives with their consequences, and finally selecting the alternative, most likely to lead to goal achievement”.

I ask how many IAS officers as of now had have listed the private sector participation (education, health, road, infra, etc) in the public policies as one of the best possible option to provide better choices to people of this country.

“L P Singh advised trainee IAS officers: “practically all government is politics — anything you do has political implication”. Actually it is the political murder!

“Adopting practices from the private sector” nonsense why there are no national or state level emphases on dying poor schools and health centres etc in India

“Political engagement is necessary because decisions made by IAS officers affect individuals, groups of people and interest groups, each having different goals and different notions to achieve their goals”. When both political and IAS officers are in vested interest what will happened to people of this country. Exactly that was happening since political independence!

How many are poor too many why no one knows the reasons!

Why poor are poor because they are poor this is what stupid babaus, polize, regulators, rulers, etc preach mindlessly.

But things are not over, yet comes the age of technology and innovation to push back State Accumulated Interest (SAI)!

The turbulence lies opportunity

Mr Vivek Gambhir writes in Economic Times that the “Economic turmoil creates more opportunities for companies to move into leadership positions than any other time in business.”

This is what the Austrian economists are arguing since long time that the market corrects itself and discover new avenues without the help of government or central bank intervention.

Federalism at Stuck

Exactly two years ago I had attended a Conference at Srinagar organized by ISS. What I was felt after the conference was that all sort of “isms” are becoming stuck.

Here is evidence from expert who writes in Economic Times “After 2000 which brought both corporate and customs duties within the divisible pool of taxes the amount to be shared with states was increased from 29.5% to 30.5% by the XIIth Finance Commission for the period 2005-2006 to 2009-2010. However, as pointed out by other analysts, the Union receipt budget suggests the devolution over the past five years has never exceeded 26% and in fact it has gone down from 28.2% in some earlier years to 26%. Substantial accruals arising from surcharge, cess and non-tax revenue have been kept out of the divisible pool. This has resulted in by-passing the recommendations of the Finance Commission to the disadvantage of the states. The Finance Commission need to ensure that governments implement what they accept in letter and spirit. There is the need for greater transparency and a redressal mechanism for the states”.

No matter how the road commission’s recommendation has gone beyond the spirit! This one proof is enough to say federalism is becoming stuck.

The Pet and Two Gentle Men- Friedrich Hayek and Michael Oakeshott

Here is an interesting article by Shoba Narayan in MINT which asks several questions and finds some answers from economists that is too from conservatives but Hayek is not a conservative!  Indeed he is true liberal.

“The question needs to be rephrased. Why do middle-aged parents choose to acquire a pet? And here comes the masochistic part. For the children — because pets teach children responsibility; pets will help them take care of one another, be compassionate towards other species and eventually save the earth. The simple act of getting a pet will reduce global warming; or at least stop the glaciers from melting. Or so we think. The reality is that kids are programmed to shrug off responsibility. They lose textbooks, forget mid-term exams, forget favourite (and expensive) toys at faraway birthday parties and treat a pet as another plaything. Sure, they will fill up water in the bowl once, maybe twice. After that, pets fall under the purview of the same beleaguered parents who were foolish enough to think that they could pass the buck. 

Since my husband thinks economics delivers the answer to most questions, I did a search on “the economics of intangible objects”, reasoning that pets offer only intangible benefits. This led me to Adam Smith, who offered a fascinating discourse on the topic of “vendible commodities”, but didn’t quite address the issue of pets. After several detours into “assertive modesty” and the economics of intangibles; into the meaning of “disposition”, ranging from progressive and conservative, I finally hit upon two gentlemen called Friedrich Hayek and Michael Oakeshott. The former, a Nobel-prize winner, is hot stuff among economists, but it was Oakeshott’s essay, On Being Conservative, that gave me answers to my questions. 

Oakeshott talks about how a conservative mindset regards change and innovation.

“Innovation,” he says, “entails certain loss and possible gain, therefore the onus of proof to show that the proposed change may be…beneficial rests on the would-be innovator.” The problem is that the would-be innovators in my household, aka kids, didn’t use this logic with respect to the dog. There was no onus of proof; only mere badgering and endless repetition of “we want a puppy”. 

Oakeshott, not surprisingly, prefers a slow rather than rapid pace with respect to innovation. In other words, get a goldfish before a puppy. He also says that the “most favourable occasion for innovation is when the projected change is most likely to be limited to what is intended and least likely to be corrupted by undesired and unmanageable consequences.” Yes, but what if the change agents didn’t have a clear view of what was intended from the change and instead got themselves mired in all kinds of unmanageable consequences, such as having to turn down all party invitations because the puppy is howling? Clearly, Oakeshott hadn’t thought that far ahead; or perhaps he hadn’t encountered irrational kids — or pups — when he came up with his clearly outlined theses”. 

 

The Nanny State

Quite revealing article by Professor Deepak Lal writes in today’s Business Standard that the “economists have found many anomalies in the standard economic model of an individual’s maximising utility……current consumption depends on past consumption but not future consumption. This omission is repaired in the rational addiction models of Becker and Murphy (Journal of Political Economy, 1988). They show how even with inter-temporally inconsistent preferences, consumers maximise utility over their life cycle taking account of the future consequences of their actions in consuming addictive substances.

Nevertheless, Prof Sen always try to make mockery this one is no surprise for me. Prof Lal further writes “this is justified by moral paternalists by basing themselves on Mill’s correct argument against a person’s freedom to sell himself into slavery, namely that “the principle of freedom cannot require that the person be free not to be free. It is not freedom to be allowed to alienate his freedom” (On Liberty, Everyman edition, p. 158). Amartya Sen (FT, 11 Feb, 2007) has claimed the smoking ban in the UK is based on Mill’s principles of liberty: “as habit-forming behaviour today restricts the freedom of the same person in the future”. But as I and others pointed out, this is a complete travesty of Mill’s argument against slavery (FT, 15 Feb 2007, and especially S Simpson, FT, 2 March 2007). Mill’s robust arguments against bans on addictive substances like alcohol and opium do not mention his argument against slavery as being relevant in any way”.

 

Monday, September 29, 2008

Individuals own their soul

Philosopher Ayn Rand wrote in her book The Virtue of Selfishness that every individual own their soul, mind and body to pursue the objective their life.

Today’s TOI editorial asks “Does the fundamental right to property also guarantee the right not to have property?” “Logically then, the fundamental right to life should also incorporate its opposite” it add.

Interestingly it mentioned that “the Bombay high court thought so too in 1986 when it held that the right to life included the right to die and struck down Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code which provides punishment for the attempt to commit suicide as unconstitutional”. 

One may ask how many farmers are punished so far for attempt to commit suicide.

But economist like Sauvik Chakraverti says that “the government has no role in individual’s soul to dictate” But he writes “those in authority have sold their souls to the Devil”.

One can also ask where the Devil is now. The answer may be is the governments department.

Dr Manmohan Singh and Bush Reactor Constructionist

The N Deal is over, whether Dr Singh party will get vote in the forthcoming General election? It is a big dilemma because except this N deal what his party did in the account of India’s reforms is also another big question that everyone now asks utterly.

Here are two news reports which say that the N Deal passing in US house and France will be done too.

A layperson or common man can ask what are the benefits that future India will gain out this N Deal yes here is an article by Jeff Immelt in Bloomberg which precisely says it will be immense! And it is also worth to note the below lines.

“The agreement is good for the U.S.-India relationship, good for global energy policy and security and good for U.S. jobs. It opens up prospects for U.S. companies to supply potentially billions of dollars worth of reactor technology, fuel and other services to India -- especially given the ambitious nuclear-plant construction program planned by India. About 30 domestic and foreign-supplied reactors may be built by 2030 alone.”