Tuesday, September 23, 2008

One has to live by Chandra

“I cannot think of him without an inadvertent smile rising to my lips. He was as quick of wit as of mind” wrote Milton Friedman to his long friendship with George Stigler.   

Further, “Stigler regarded economic theory, in the words of Alfred Marshall, as "an engine for the discovery of concrete truth,"

Many more interesting read it full article here though both of them no more today.

I am immensely benefited by Milton Friedman writings including this one which I read first today!

 

On Race for Prize by Chandra

The Sveriges Bank Prize in Economic Science in Memory of Alfred Nobel for 2008 has started to blow.

The econoSpeak has it own hunch on leading economists. Among theme there are two Indian born economists in the list.

William Baumol, for lots of things

Jagdish Bhagwati with Avinash Dixit, for international trade theory
Gordon Tullock with Anne Krueger, for rent seeking
Benoit Mandelbrot, possibly with Eugene Fama, just to freak everybody out, although Mandelbrot is the more deserving in my view (for complexity) but certainly for recognizing the reality of fat tails in financial markets, now more evident than ever (if they give it Fama and not Mandelbrot, that would be a ridiculous farce).
Richard Easterlin, for happiness. He is the man on that one, and deserving. Of this group, it is him and Mandelbrot whom I would most like to see.

BTW, to Brenda, there ought to be one for ecological economics, but I doubt this is the year, and I am not sure who should get it.

 

Economic Freedom mattered more equally as Political Freedom by Chandra

Prominent liberal Thomas Sowell wrote in his book Applied Economic Thinking Beyond Stage One. One student asked to professor, where do slave come from? But Prof replied the question is wrong one should ask where freedom comes from.

Freedom means life is in mutual with other fellow man and women. There is political freedom and there is economic freedom. Another Nobel Prize winner and economist Milton Friedman wrote in his famous book on Capitalism and Freedom, this book has important analysis of political and economic freedom.

I once had an opportunity to read this book in 2002 but could not understand fully give the background of my muddled socialist professors.

But I reread the book in 2007 and strongly feel that every student should read this book irrespective of their previous training in their subjects.  

Now there is news report which says that “India's ranking in the index, which scales prosperity of the whole society, is down by 8 notches to 77th position among 141 countries in 2006, with uneven pattern of economic reforms widening gap between the rich and the poor”, 

There is also reports view in these rich and poor divide myths.

“"Unequal distribution of Economic Freedom is at the basis of India's uneven development. The reason is simple, the areas in which the middle and upper classes make their living have seen the highest degree of liberalisation, while the areas in which the poor earn their livelihood have seen the fewest reforms," it said. The rating on a scale of 10 declined from 6.6 to 6.59.? 

“Among the five components of the EFW index, the largest decline for India is in 'Sound Money' where its score decreased to 6.70 in 2006, with the country ranking at the 113th position, from 7.0 in 2005”. 

One can deem this decline may be the damages done by RBI and the Government  which still fails to reaslise “there is a strong connection between economic freedom and common well-being. Countries with higher economic freedom have higher average per-capita GDP and average per-capita economic growth”. 

It is quite interesting one read the following articles on Friedman

The man who helped millions escape poverty by Ila Patnaik  

Friedman on India by Parth J Shah

 

 


Miracles is the nature of market by Chandra

Rajrishi Singhal writes “Markets have also evolved from their original mission of being essentially an efficient and cheap mechanism for firm-level capital allocation”.

And further

“Here’s what David Strom, president of Minnesota Free Market Institute, wrote in a recent article: “Businesses often make huge mistakes, and we have known for centuries that markets are constantly fluctuating, even wildly... Markets, though, correct... Markets work well — not perfectly, but well — because they are not engineered from the top-down. They are chaotic. They encourage experimentation. They allow mistakes. In markets, even the mighty can fall. Not so in regulated markets.” 

“there is always someone who has more information than the others”. This is what years ago liberal economist and Nobel Prize winner F A Hayek said in his fames essay on "The use of Knowledge in Society" published in 1945.

 

Prof Jagdish Bhagwati strong statement on Globalisation by Chandra

Here an interesting video talk by Prof Jagdish Bhagwati,


Scrap that call by Chandra

It the murky mind if any one believes the below lines. Even they do turn to advocate in future as with out complete break from the dogmatic arguments.

“The CPI(M) argument is less profound and more pragmatic. It is a party that believes in progress and modernization”.

Read the full article here 

Poor love thy Kapital, Kapital by Chandra

“Communists probably believe that Karl Marx’s grave is nothing but a capitalist plot. And in that capitalist plot it is likely that Marx is laughing away while exclaiming, “Kapital, Kapital.”

But Sauvik Chakraverti wrote in The Times of India in 2005, such one in its own character.

“The very fact that all this capital is available for the worker to work upon raises his productivity and his earnings. The capital is there only because the shareholders of the company have saved enough to invest in the firm. Left to the workers, their savings would not have generated such a lot of investment in capital. Thus, as with the hammer and the sickle, when workers get advanced robotics to work with, the ensuing increase in labour productivity translates into higher earnings per worker. Labour and capital are hence in harmony”. 

 

Corrupt Govt & Co Ltd by Chandra

The media always hanging on the other side of blaming game of corrupt politicians and the governments as well but it does the job most of the time wrongly.

There is no proper law or system to manage the 100s of political parties of India even after sixty years.

This was the subject of our present finance minister once wrote a piece in the Indian Express news paper. The same question one can also ask now. What he is doing to bring out the meaningful law to govern the different political parties which are otherwise called prime polluter of our society?

The motion should set to bring out such law, so the need of the hour here is the media, academic, industries, bribed politicians and of course the legal system without this country is no country as such.

Economic Freedom and Democracy by Chandra

“It is representative, but not participatory, when ideally it should be both”.

Quite interesting book review but exciting to read. 

John Maynard Keynes dead but We Live? By Chandra

Any way Keynes is down now?

“Keynes alone was confident that he could fix capitalism so as to cure it of its cyclical tendencies, but he was over-optimistic”.

It is hard to believe if one has studied the principles of free market economics fully or at least the works done by Miese, F A Hayek, Milton Friedman, to mention a few.

One can ask how far Keynes had such “over optimistic”

But it is our own job to test what the rationale of saying that the “The old truth that Keynes wrote about in the superb Chapter 12 of General Theory is still valid. People prefer being wrong in a herd than being right in isolation. They have a collective amnesia when it suits them, and the longer the bull run lasts, the more the stock market resembles a casino”.

Because one reason is that no Economics department in India teach truth about the different sort of economic systems and its principles least in my knowledge.

But it is debatable issue when it come “The eternal verities of Marx and Hayek”  

 

Private Property Right Economic Freedom by Chandra

Whenever people, experts and policy makers even legal pundits, it is the basic rights if any man living for their livelihood. I first thought of the private property is alright for the person who owns the land. What about the masses who is not owner of any single property. This is thinking in stage one only.

Think if any one says, the same masses do not own any land or private property. Did they not live on this earth? It means obviously they are part of our society and have some sort of same private property right where they are all living with others and share the common private property right which the Government supposes to ensure by all means. Therefore, it is the basic human natural order or right to have private property and thereby allocate the resources do to their (people) business with others and create wealth to enrich better standard of life and the same for every body else’s.

Even economist Thomas Sowell has also written elsewhere about this idea. Particularly in his book on “Applied Economics Thinking beyond State one”

Many experts have written excellent pieces on this topic. There is scholarly one here by liberal economist Walter E. Williams.

Indeed it is worthy to note the below lines:

“As Thomas Sowell writes in Knowledge and Decisions, “It is precisely those things which belong to ‘the people’ which have historically been despoiled—wild creatures, the air, and waterways being notable examples. This goes to the heart of why property rights are socially important in the first place. Property rights mean self-interested monitors. No owned creatures are in danger of extinction. No owned forests are in danger of being leveled. No one kills the goose that lays the golden egg when it is his goose.”

 Aristotle said, “What is common to many is taken least care of, for all men have greater regard for what is their own than for what they possess in common with others.” What he is saying is that private property rights force people to internalize externalities, which is just a fancy way of saying that a person’s wealth is held hostage to his doing the “socially responsible” thing—wisely using the planet’s scarce resources. Private property rights induce the homeowner to take into account the effect of his current use of the property on its future value. That is why we expect a homeowner to give better care to a house than a renter. A homeowner has a greater stake in what a house is worth ten or 20 years later. An owner would more likely make sacrifices and take the kind of care that lengthens the usable life of the house. He reaps the reward from doing so, or pays the penalty for not doing so. Owners require security deposits against damage to make renters share some of their interests in the property”.

It is not surprise if any one mentions that in India we lost that private property rights from our Constitutional Fundamental Rights way back in 1978. Originally, the right to property was also included in the Fundamental Rights; however, the Forty-fourth Amendment, passed in 1978, revised the status of property rights by stating that "No person shall be deprived of his property save by authority of law."

Perhaps one can say the present SEZs land issues across the states is directly related to unavailability of private property right under fundamental right.

It is also interesting some you could read the following articles.

The right to property  by ] 

Kaushik Das


Property rights attack continues by Walter E. Williams. 

Chapter 4: Private Property Rights 

A Constitution Based On Property Rights? by Parth J. Shah

A Second Republic | There Can Be No Collective Property by Sauvik Chakraverti 


Monday, September 22, 2008

Make Education Freedom work for children by Chandra

Where there is less freedom there will be more brutal which is evident in the Indian education system particularly in school education.

This brutalism is not only created by Governments after, Plan after plans, committee after committees so and so forth always accumulated by bad legal system in the our country and the education freedom remains under severe brutalism.

There is a quite interesting news report in today’s Business Standard. But the brutalism still continues in almost all the States education system from Pre School to University education.

There is other brutalism called Teacher Unionism which always tries to underestimate what the poor children wanted from Governments as well as private schools.

 

Governments Sans Individual Freedom is absurd by Chandra

It is the irrational human action, stupid. Who can see the economic activity is totally different from any other activity? If at all it is only the human activity which include both economic and social. It is the later development or looking at things different way is also called social activity. Suppose there is something called economic activity which aims at creating or accumulating wealth for once survivals. This particular activity whichever it may naturally includes social activity.   

There is an article in today’s Economic Times, which start with anomaly by forced muse on Economics. One can not draw separate line between social and economic activity from the same the human action, I mean his or her action is the same but viewed by different people in different perspective than how come “It does not interest us because we have so easily managed to separate what we see as economic activity from the rest of society? It further state that “Even our economics has narrowed down to money and profits”. The author themselves are not clear what they wanted to say but it is clear they wanted to kill the world ‘profit’ like one did by our first prime minister Nehru!

Instead of saying “we are so skewed in out vision” the life is in conflict of visions which is also often shared by every one of us.

Let’s agree with this “only from the point of view of profit”. What the so called BIG Governments are really doing?

No doubts they are not trying to bridge people equitable (both rich and poor). So let’s not ask them to do any more, if at all ask our freedom to do our basic actions. These socialist human rightist are always in confused mode, let’s not try to tune them, they will kill us by breaching social justice, no profit out of fair business or no free trade etc.

It is worth to note one by great Tamil poet Subrahmanya Bharathi said

“We will dig many mines,

And take out gold and other things,

And go eight directions to sell these,

And bring home many things”.

(India 2020 A Vision for the New Millennium by A P J Abdul Kalam with Y S Rajasn, p.87).

 What I am saying is that we need to consider all other ideas and muse it as it goes but separate one from your own way and then bring it from your on thought to practice become taking as it is from others.

A Humane Tribute to Sudha Shenoy (1943-2008) by Chandra

I first heard Sudha Shenoy quickly after I attended the first ever (as of now) Austrian Economics Seminar in India in 2005 nicely organized by Centre for Civil Society, is a Delhi based Free Market think tank.

It was the 2003 such one enthusiastic but Sudha Shenoy interview led me to read more about her other writings.

I have also written a brief biography of her fascinated father and the true Indian economist Professor B R Shenoy which I will upload shortly.

There is also humane brief bio of Sudha Shenoy which has some more interesting information. Some of you may be interested to know!

All I can say is that the world has lost one of our true liberal economists but often my likeminded distinguished economists tell their ideas never get loss its value from this world.

Sudha Shenoy’s last writing is here, but not doubts it is quite readable in fact it is worth to note the following lines.

"Technology is widely seen as the key to development. But this does not explain how a single innovative machine multiplies itself. An alternative tack: Menger’s analysis of investment chains. Begin with first-order (consumer) goods and examine the second, third-, and other successively higher-order goods required......".

The Prof B R Shenoy's interesting two books later edited and bublished.

The above books also available here and here


Thursday, September 18, 2008

It is the economic systems, stupid by Chandra

It is quite familiar among socialist after John Maynard Keynes expressed this jargon line or quote, it read “When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?” Note that where he (Mr Keynes) expressed this line, only few knew well.

Just honestly remember what the real brilliant economist said “As the hypnotic mantra of "change" is repeated endlessly, few people even raise the question of whether what few specifics we hear represent any real change, much less a change for the better.”

It is this jargon line well admired by some of Indian semi liberals! Otherwise they themselves clime as liberal! Nonsense!

One can quote several good things which have explored by facts as it stands but not how and when it get changed. Hardly did it change.

Because the “facts are stubborn things, and whatever may be our wishes, our inclinations, or the dictates of our passions, they cannot alter the state of facts and evidence- John Adams. (Basic Economics by Thomas Sowell, p.21).

Stupidities never become brilliant any more.