Wednesday, September 17, 2008

1 dollar= 20 Rupee or even less by Chandra

Why socialist (Economics) professors don’t teach a simple fact about weak rupee and strong rupee?

Why Indian Commerce Minister doesn’t preach rupee appreciation?

Who will gain from rupee appreciation and who will not?

No jargon nothing. There are many way by which one can look into the simple economics of rupee appreciation and depreciation.

If the Indian rupee get stronger or otherwise appreciates against say US dollar it is good for every poor people in India, so that they get cheaper imported goods with high quality. In the case of good quality products which is not available within India is doubly welcome.

Of course the domestic industries will get affect and may lead to more employment losses. It doesn’t mean that the poor people should sacrifice their natural right to access the cheaper goods from other country.

If the rupee appreciates by which the particular industry faces greater challenges should be read for the alternative arrangement without taxing the poor people little choice.

No doubt the Government officials, ministers may wolf cry for foreign exchange reserve, this and that by lobbing. But they will never serve for poor people after they voted into power. 

April 11 2008 is the day I felt amazing and more excited to purchase more stuffs usually liberal economists books but could not make use of that. That day the Indian rupee was at 39.98 for per US dollar.

The above story led me from the today’s news which I read in the Business Line “Rupee crashes by 90 paise”, in which Mr Kamal Nath, who is India’s Commerce Minister lauds stupidly “We have allowed rupee to move from 39 to 46 against the dollar. We should not calibrate. Not calibrating it shows the strength of our institutional systems and that the best practices have been adhered to in Asia”.

Is the right way to ‘strengthen our institutional system?’ or is the babus way of stealing poor people choices?

There is strong case from my side. For instance, the persons like me could not buy the book which has been published way back several decades. See the below list: 

Book Name

Price

In Indian rupee

In US$

Economic Facts & Fallacies  by Thomas Sowell (Hardcover - 2008)

913

17.16

A Man of Letters by Thomas Sowell

1251

19.77

Basic Economics 3rd Ed: A Common Sense Guide to the Economy by Thomas Sowell(Hardcover - April 2, 2007)

1238

26.37

Applied Economics: Thinking Beyond Stage One by Thomas Sowell (Hardcover - Nov 11, 2003)

930

19.80

Hayek Collection

5166

110

Hayek on Hayek

1503

32

Individualism and Economic Order

986

21

Boehm-Bawerk Collection

5213

111

The millions of poor people and even non poor in India have hundred of things in list like mine (still goes long). Therefore there is no harm in the rupee appreciation (against US dollar) which is actually good for people. More the imports of quality goods attribute to more the rich people and innovate domestically more than they import further.

In other words Mr Kamal Nath is indeed producing more poverty or depraving poor people’s choice which is not permitted in the constitution. “No person shall not be deprived any of his or her basic choices which are essential for the life and that never be a sufficient condition.

There is other interesting post on this issue by Indian liberal economist Sauvik Chakraverti 

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Invisible Doctors by Chandra

Can Economics doctorates put injection to people who fall in ill? To answer this question there was interesting experience in my life. One was happened in my college days and another one was happened when I was graduated and went to see village people.

Let’s look into the first one.

Way back in 2002, we were in the final year of B. A. Economics in Gurunanak College, (Madras University), one of my friend Philips Alexander first time saw our Head of Department’s (HOD) name board outside his room he was so sock! It was written like this Dr.G.Ananthapadmanabhan. Then he told us “you know our HOD is Doctor, I saw in the name board I think he can put injection also I did knew that!”

Some of my friends were enjoying such a funny joke mamus? In fact it was quite amazing to see how one could be. It was not his fault at all. The kind of teachers taught like that. It was also true that part of school education also mattered.

The second one was as I said happened in my village, interestingly twice the same person.

When I went to my village after I got my B A Economic degree in June 2002. As my parents did not know not heard what is all about the degree. They only knew and often telling other that the one who get degree become “Collector officer” in India it is IAS babaus!

Then, some my neighbors who asked me what are you going to do further? I am going to do masters in economics I said.

Further, they asked then, I said I am going to do M. Phil and then Doctorate then finally they told me that so “you can also open a clinic in our home town, Gingee after you become doctorate!

The B A graduated that is too in economics and the so called illiterate thinking are same with minor change in situation where they live.

For a moment I was unable to realize what they said. It was not their fault again, they can still write only their name! But all of them were born after the India’s political Independence and the Nehru’s Socialist dogmatic policies which actually killed millions of people including my neighbor’s life that has terribly gone without seeing the India as well as the world map!

Why I am writing this piece it is very simple. I was reading an article on “Doctor? That don’t impress me much” by Rajrishi Singhal, Columns in The Economic Times.

Interestingly as I have naturally experience it was not a surprise after reading this line 

“A passenger once fainted on the deck of a Mediterranean liner (this is long before the modern version of cruise holidays). The officer on duty immediately shouted: “Is there a doctor on board?” Instantly, four people rushed ahead, but on seeing the patient, shook their heads and wished to be excused. They were doctors all right, but none of them had the requisite medical education”. 

The rest of the story I fully agree with him. In fact among the present so called Indian economists, I have some more list of persons who was awarded doctorates!

In the same final year one of our teacher told us the 'Economic Political and Weekly' is not available in Chennai that was altogether different story!

But the sad one is that still many of the Indian universities economics department teachers don't understand the EPW dogmatic view in economic policy!


Thursday, September 11, 2008

Economics of Blogs Games by Chandra

Yesterday years debate in schools, colleges and university near not gone yet new order of F A Hayek bloger games begin.

There is a new blog called http://catallactics.blog.com/  in India quite young but he attempts new experiments in applied economics.

Of course my answers are attempted here in brief!    

My hunch!

Defiantly the notes physical quality will vary as along as the Government/ Central bank promises it is used as monopoly legal tender!

If at all the notes physical quality varies it is due to the velocity of circulation among people who were used for trading goods and services by the Central bank/ government promised notes!

All notes will disappear only when the Central Bank/Government stops printing of new notes! Or the trading of goods and services of people who changed in a given period of time or people themselves trade all goods and services without any form of central bank/government printed monopoly money including old one!

 I am looking forward your answer

 

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

Of the Economics language by Chandra

How people learn a particular idea or language without difficulty. A slight similar question was also asked by Swami Vivekananda more than hundred years ago! But let’s focus what F A Hayek wrote in one of his book.

“spontaneously grown institutions such as language, law, morals, and conventions that anticipated modern scientific approaches and from which the liberals might have profited. But the admiration of the conservatives for free growth generally applies only to the past. They typically lack the courage to welcome the same undesigned change from which new tools of human endeavors will emerge”.

Of course Hayek was arguing about the inability of conservative understanding on natural institutions and its viability to every one when it has been promoted.

When it comes the learning of “Economics is generally considered as a “dry” subject by students. Its teachers face a challenge in generating interest among their students for economics”. There is a valid reason’s for this situation. Apart from all other reasons “One of the most striking things was the frequent assertion by the economists I met was that they didn’t read the business papers. This strange approach doesn’t seem to have changed much. Just two days ago, I met a university professor who said the same thing. I wondered about the point of the research they did. If, like their counterparts in the US and the rest of the west, they didn’t address live problems, what did they do then? And why?”

It is true the teachers who are in the field of economics don’t have nobility of teaching themselves that is one of the major reasons for their inability to train students.

They don’t even understand what liberal economist Adam Smith said more than two hundred years ago! “The teachers had no jurisdiction over their pupils, nor any other authority besides that natural authority, which superior virtue and abilities never fail to procure from young people towards those who are entrusted with any part of their education”.

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

Who can write poem by the expenses of Public money? By Chandra

Many politicians do many things except in the interest of people who were elected these so called representatives who actually represent themselves for their interest not.

An Indian politician does some what different, let’s see.

"Dear Atalji I must confess It is time to clear up all this mess. Let us (something) deal with unfinished tasks and see the man behind the mask December 6th this nation saw gross violation of the law In retrospect you said this meant an expression of national sentiment

Don’t send me an sms to tell me that you love me I do not want to be that quickly erased from your memory.

I miss the smell of burning waste. The wake up call of temple bells And vendors who I chatter with Bargaining as they sell.

I haven’t spared the media. I have spared anybody. I haven’t spared the bureaucracy.There is a poem called ‘Smooth Sailing’ as to how a file moves in the bureaucratic system. When the minister wants it to move it quickly, how the Newton’s law of gravity slows it down. And it says:

The bureaucrats have finally tuned Newton’s law of motion Every action must be opposed with an equally robust reaction.

Our bureaucrats have finally tweaked Newton’s famous law of motion Positive actions must be opposed with a robust negative reaction Policy prescriptions when in place the Minister states with clarity This slow down movement of the files taking recourse to law of gravity Those requiring urgent action kept at the bottom of the pile Prepare a detailed list of objections which actions cannot reconcile Convoluted archaic rules not understanding simple facts Persuade the minister to invoke omnibus powers to relax Then opine,that such authority if he dares to ever use
Has the potential of making him a suspect if not an accused Most of our national projects will acquire enough maturity with time Moving forward at snail’s pace given the bureaucratic mind At the time of implementation all essential parameters change Bureaucrats then advise the Minister to start all over again.


The Left has suffered for a lifetime now, of an ailment they can’t diagnose The symptom however that troubles them most is that they can’t see beyond their nose. Doc Basu warned them of the precipice ahead, gave them medicine to prevent them fall The healer Surjeet, with practical tips, weaned them away from the Das Kapital They were then advised to see an optician for a possible vision transplant For an alternative way to prosperity for the poor who suffer from wants Manmohan, the doc, had a solution in mind, promised to do whatever he can They had to listen to him beyond the regime called the common minimum programme To see beyond the nose we must energise the mind, clogged, confused and unfreeDoc Manmohan believed, after studies revealed,that the way out was the 1...2...3.

Convincing those with their vision impaired, earning their ire and opprobrium Was no mean task, for what we needed most was in a short supply, of uranium This fissile material with our reactors in place would aid in clearing the mind But fossilized thoughts, ranted and raved, saw Opposition completely blind Frustrated he thought that in changing tack he had an outside chance to succeed Without energy supply his patience would die Though the afflicted needed time to concede With objectives achieved their mind will mutate They will begin to relearn as they see our actions will display Clearing the way for our energy autonomy.

The Indo-US nuclear deal now a bone of contention With the BJP’s turn about and the Left’s apprehension Imperialist designs cited as reason for suspicion One hoped left the ideology had evolved through transition Dismantling of the Berlin wall, the fall of the Iron Curtain No Gorbachev of Indian mould, after Basu the future uncertain.

Free press challenge today by corporate world Making news like other products commercially sold Advertising revenue drives content for gratification Commercial interest shamelessly receive undue articulation Electronic media through images that sensationalise In the process their credibility seriously jeopardize Bollywood geeks, cricket icons make headline news What stars foretell, conman tricks meant to infuse TRPs of channels, soap operas get hits for you News that matter, serious content, of limited value Online information, instant coffee, no time to brew.

That might not have suited for all those who wanted to embarrass the government that they Politics lost its veneer, as it would appear wads of notes on vulgar display We were all in a stupor, felt cheated and let down by those we hold in esteem Can’t compromise the nation by belittling its systems not upholding its glory pristine The government had won, democracy the loser and politics in utter disarray This temple of justice invaded by avarice Yet the nation will still have its way.

Every time you met me, your arrival woefully late I stood somewhat embarrassed outside your college gate Those who saw me waiting smiled knowingly at me A site that they had witnessed ever so frequently You noticed not my protests and with an open smile Expressed regrets that yet again I had waited for a while We waited for the sun to set to hold each other tight Nocturnal prowl the chowkidaar sentinel of the night Spotted with his flashy torch both in disheveled state Ensuring that potential sinners must never fall from grace.

Meeting in London. I dread to meet at Oxford street The same old faces exchanging usual graces Backslapping each other How are you brother Enjoying the weather. All family together. Away from the heat, Holiday complete And wife is busy on a shopping tizzy Makes her happy Buying for child They all going wild Picking up clothing Almost for nothing Best part is, sir This is like ghar".

See the full interview

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Adam Smith- A Primer or Frontier by Chandra

It is the nation and its men who do things better by trying every alternatives, no harm in that. Than where is the question of need of Government yes they do need but stupidly for only to protect men from external conflicts.
Here is a simple idea of what the man is all about in an economy written plain language by EAMONN BUTLER, Director of Adam Smith Institute.

"The wealth of a nation is not, as the mercantilists believed, the quantity of gold and silver in its vaults, but the total of its production and commerce – what today we would call gross domestic product.

In a free exchange both sides become better off. Nobody would enter an exchange if they expected to lose from it. Imports are therefore just as valuable to us as exports are
to others. We do not need to impoverish others to enrich ourselves. Indeed, we have more to gain if our customers are wealthy.

Regulations on commerce are ill founded and counterproductive. Prosperity is threatened by taxes, import tariffs, export subsidies and preferences for domestic industries.

A nation’s productive capacity rests on the division of labour and the accumulation of capital it makes possible. Huge increases in output can be gained by breaking down
production into many small tasks, each undertaken by specialist hands. This leaves producers with a surplus for investment.

A country’s future income depends on the rate of capital accumulation. The more that is invested in better productive processes, the more wealth will be created in the future.

When there is free trade and competition the market system automatically remains focused on the most urgent needs. Where things are scarce, people are prepared to pay more for them. There is more pro. t in supplying them, so producers invest capital in order to produce more.

Prosperity grows most rapidly when there is an open, competitive marketplace, with free exchange and without coercion. Defence, justice and the rule of law are needed to maintain this openness. Freedom and self-interest do not lead to chaos, but – as if guided by an ‘invisible hand’ – produce order and concord.

Vested interests use government power to distort the market system for their own benefit. Employers and professionals may promote regulations that stifle competition, such as
entry barriers that prevent people from practicing particular trades.

Taxes should be proportionate to income and ought to be certain and convenient to pay. They should be cheap to collect, should not hamper business, should not be so onerous as to encourage evasion and should not require frequent visits from tax gatherers.

Human beings have a natural ‘sympathy’ (or empathy) for others. This enables them to moderate their behaviour and preserve harmony. It is also the basis of moral judgements about behaviour and the source of human virtue. Human nature is a better guide to the creation of a harmonious society than the overweening reason of zealots and visionaries".

The Full paper!

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Statism, Socialism and Monopoly Government is not Free by Chandra

Mr Rahul Bajaj, Chairman, Bajaj Auto, said that “for long, the developing world had been conceding ground to the developed world and this had to change now.” He said “I prefer a no deal rather than a bad deal.”

It is the same story about the failed Indian State which is by no means for poor to prefer a no deal rather than a bad deal……..but by every means it works for bureaucratic welfare and is not for below poverty welfare.

Today
Barry Loberfeld has article which not only ask several crucial questions but make reader to muse!

It very important to note the below lines to think through!

We know Madison and his politics of limited government, we know Jefferson and his morality of individual rights, but we often forget Paine and his philosophy of the primacy of society over the State:

A great part of that order which reigns among mankind is not the effect of government. It had its origin in the principles of society and the natural constitution of man. It existed prior to government, and would exist if the formality of government was abolished. The mutual dependence and reciprocal interest which man has upon man, and all parts of a civilized community upon each other, create that great chain of connection which holds it together. The landholder, the farmer, the manufacturer, the merchant, the tradesman, and every occupation, prospers by the aid which each receives from the other, and from the whole. Common interest regulates their concerns, and forms their laws; and the laws which common usage ordains, have a greater influence than the laws of government. In fine, society performs for itself almost every thing which is ascribed to government.

Thursday, August 7, 2008

Who won the Annual Bastiat Prize for Journalism in India? by Chandra

It was the year 2002 the radical free market economist Mr Sauvik Chakraverti (India), columnist, Economic Times won the prize along with Amity Shlaes (USA), columnist, Financial Times and once again put the free society ideas on triumph!

The following are the articles which were nominated for this prize! It is an extremely readable one for all.

1.
On Scarcity...and Abundance, The Economic Times, 28 January 2002
2.
Teacher, Don't Teach Nonsense! The Economic Times , 26 March 2002
3.
Liberals Must Dump Gandhi, The Economics Times, 24 February 2002

More here

In 2005 Mr Dinakar Sethuraman (India), Contributing Editor, Forbes Global and Ila Patnaik (India), Economics Editor, Indian Express were in the finalist for the prize.

And not finally……….Mr Amit Varma (India), Mint won the prize in 2007. His articles are equally readable! The nominated articles are here:

It is quite amazing to see how too late to g..e..t..the Bastiat Price for Journalism from India Mr Swaminathan S Anklesaria Aiyar, the man who is afraid of nothing in the economics journalism! He is one of the finalists for 2008 annual Bastiat Price!

Congratulations Mr Swamination!
The IPN network

Saturday, July 26, 2008

The early musings of Prof F A Hayek by Chandra

The Mises Institute has just released a new edition of Hayek’s early works on economic theory, Prices and Production and Other Works: F. A. Hayek on Money, the Business Cycle, and the Gold Standard, edited and introduced by Joe Salerno. It collects the monographs Prices and Production, Monetary Theory and the Trade Cycle, and Monetary Nationalism and International Stability, along with the important essays “The Paradox of Saving,”

Joseph T. Salerno who is the editor of this book

Here is a detailed Hayek bibliography (through 1982) compiled by Leonard Liggio. Here’s a biographical essay written by yours truly. Here is the home page of the Collected Works of F. A. Hayek (and a pointer to my favorite volume). And it’s never too early to begin preparations for this important holiday.

Saturday, July 19, 2008

Press is sun in Society to Report Facts not Fallacies by Chandra

First I heard several commentaries on press fallacies in reporting news in every day life.

There is lack of research and tactful analysis in India. In BS, TCA have written two important economic way of thinking article which is must read article to every citizen of this country.
The problem that is the media

The economics of bad media
But in USA, at least some or other economists are pressing the press fallacies in news reporting. Do read here the Dr. Arthur B. Laffer written a paper.

Men and Nation do Things by Trying Every Alternative by Chandra

There are two interesting news one was recently published by David Brooks in NYTNS. It is really excellence line:

“For a time, it seemed as if we were about to use the bright beam of science to illuminate the murky world of human action. Instead, as Turkheimer writes in his chapter in the book, “Wrestling With Behavioral Genetics,” science finds itself enmeshed with social science and the humanities in what researchers call the Gloomy Prospect, the ineffable mystery of why people do what they do.

The prospect may be gloomy for those who seek to understand human behavior, but the flip side is the reminder that each of us is a Luxurious Growth. Our lives are not determined by uniform processes. Instead, human behavior is complex, nonlinear and unpredictable. The Brave New World is far away. Novels and history can still produce insights into human behavior that science can’t match.

Just as important is the implication for politics. Starting in the late 19th century, eugenicists used primitive ideas about genetics to try to re-engineer the human race. In the 20th century, communists used primitive ideas about “scientific materialism” to try to re-engineer a New Soviet Man.

Today, we have access to our own genetic recipe. But we seem not to be falling into the arrogant temptation — to try to re-engineer society on the basis of what we think we know. Saying farewell to the sort of horrible social engineering projects that dominated the 20th century is a major example of human progress.

We can strive to eliminate that multivariate thing we call poverty. We can take people out of environments that (somehow) produce bad outcomes and try to immerse them into environments that (somehow) produce better ones. But we’re not close to understanding how A leads to B, and probably never will be.

This age of tremendous scientific achievement has underlined an ancient philosophic truth — that there are severe limits to what we know and can know; that the best political actions are incremental, respectful toward accumulated practice and more attuned to particular circumstances than universal laws”.

And another one was published in the National Review.

In the 1937 essay "Economics and Knowledge," Hayek formulated the "knowledge problem" this way: "How can the combination of fragments of knowledge existing in different minds bring about results which, if they were to be brought about deliberately, would require a knowledge on the part of the directing mind which no single person can possess?" Hayek's answer was that market institutions manage to gather the "fragments of knowledge" and coordinate individuals toward efficient outcomes. No one knows just what combination of production inputs will minimize costs and produce the quantity of goods that satisfies demand. But the operations of the market, in which prices are not fixed but respond to changes in supply and demand, are a "discovery procedure" (as Hayek would later put it) for such information.

……….as Hayek explained in the 1939 pamphlet "Freedom and the Economic System," "impose upon the people the detailed code of values that is lacking" — paving a path toward despotism.)

Both these two articles are nothing but the Professor F A Hayek ideas was well researched scientific theses, premised as individuals do things based on what they possess as knowledge no central planners can gather those idea from each. In fact Professor Hayek coined broadly these processes as spontaneous order which in the market allocate the resources efficiently than the Government.

Friday, July 18, 2008

Really!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! By Chandra


One Liberal economist, based in India, New Delhi writes in livemint as a GUESTVIEW, it read “It is the economy, stupid!”, what does mean this, the people who live, lived, born and died in this country are the only, how it is bound be like that, but the author does says that, even not means. In other words, it is the people those who engaged in unrealistic bites with words in the economy.

Except the above line I totally agree with author.

Order! Order whose? By Chandra


When I read the article OURVIEW yesterday livemint news paper it sited quote from Nobel winning economist, it read “Nobel economist Douglass North has divided human societies into two categories. First, “limited access orders” which create orders by using the political system to limit economic participation, a process that creates excess profits (or what economists call rents). These rents are used to impose political stability and limit violence. Second, “open access orders” which maintain order by competition rather than rent seeking”.

Apparently, it shows that the coercion is the former system and the F A Hayek musings of spontaneous order is the later one where individuals are the orders and decision makers.

Luckily I have North book (Understanding the Process of Economic Change) in front of me, when I write this. When I saw this book first time in 2006 I come crossed two interesting lines in the book. They are as follow:

“Uncertainty has a long history in economic literature” p.13

“The development of well specified property rights, for example, will make the overall environment more predicable but will increase uncertainty for those who traditionally have used the land in question without having formal title. Hence an essential question we must ask is, who makes the rules and for whom and what are their objectives”. He went on to say “individuals are the decision makers”…. “and market has the lowest production and transition costs attainable” p.15.

This book is everyone must read book!


In fact the 1st Chapter of the book is available in online go ahead and muse what change he premise.

Thursday, July 17, 2008

Choice is life by Chandra

Life is feasible for people when they have access of many choices in things which are essentials. A student written (UC Berkeley) his PhD theses in 88 pages only! that is too in Economics. It is shocking me I have never heard nor seen any such kind of theses in Indian universities. Indian universities produces theses minimum of 200 pages. Maximum it may goes to what the supervisor think note that not what the research area or topic reveal not even what the student muse on the topic. Tragedy tragedy!. Quality matters in research analysis.
Recently I read a Indian economist CV, it was 74 page!

Check out here, though one can not simple understand the concept unless have expertise on the subject.

Wednesday, July 16, 2008

Matrix of Ideas Transmission by Chandra

There is several ways to transmit the idea among human beings but no other method evolved on this earth except involving people.
"A teacher is the architect of future generation and hence the future of India depends upon the teacher to a great extent".
This article pity focused from student’s point of view. It reminds me several occasions where I encountered such absurd teachers, professors in class rooms in my school and college days.
There is also another article (Awakening a slumbering elephant: CCS in India) by respected free market economist in India is Dr Parth J Shah, President of the liberal think tank ‘Centre for Civil Society’ . He tells four different type of targeting the future generation to transmit the idea.
It really awake me to open the eye to imagine how one could march towards self sufficient of knowledge in a particular field or in institution or in society etc amazing when I realize the actions of ideas around the world played by human beings.

He engages reader quite well! Do read 7th article published in a book by IEA, London.