Showing posts with label Rationality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rationality. Show all posts

Friday, September 17, 2010

Undo rationalist

From Mr.Swami Vivekananda’s The First Step towards Jnana:

  • To be a rationalist requires more than unbelief. You must be able not only to reason, but also to follow the dictates of your reason. If reason tells you that this body is an illusion, are you ready to give it up? Reason tells you that heat and cold are mere illusions of your senses; are you ready to brave these things? If reason tells you that nothing that the senses convey to your mind is true, are you ready to deny your sense perception? If you dare, you are a rationalist.

  • It is very hard to believe in reason and follow truth. This whole world is full either of the superstitious or of half-hearted hypocrites. I would rather side with superstition and ignorance than stand with these half-hearted hypocrites. They are no good. They stand on both sides of the river.

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

The Empirical Economist: Dan Ariely


Robert Langreth writes:

  • His second book, The Upside of Irrationality, comes out in June. In one chapter he describes experiments suggesting that large bonuses won't improve executive performance. He teamed up with Carnegie Mellon economist George Loewenstein and others to test 87 residents of a poor village in India on a variety of tasks involving memory, fine motor skills and creativity. Some were promised a few hours or few weeks of pay if they did the tasks well. Others could get much larger bonuses--the local equivalent of six months of pay. Performance plummeted when people knew they were in the big-bonus pool. "The way to understand it is we are rediscovering choking with money," Ariely says. "For some reason nobody ever thought this applies to bonuses with executives."
  • Ariely says textbook economics is a fine approximation of the world--perhaps half of the time. The problem is that "we take economics too seriously as a society" and assume it works all the time. The world, he says, would be better off if economists spent more time in the field. "In every other field of science data is worth more than theory," he says. Unlike some behavioral economists who focus on high finance, Ariely looks broadly at everyday decision making. He has a knack for taking a complex phenomenon and encapsulating it in a simple experiment. One set of experiments shows that college students are more likely to cheat on a task with financial rewards when they know a confederate from the same university is doing it and getting away with it. If they know someone from a rival school is cheating, they are less likely to cheat.
  • Standard economics, Ariely argues, provides few solutions to the world's problems because it assumes people are making perfect decisions. "People are making mediocre decisions. If you get them to make better decisions, you might have a better world."